stock here:




stock here:




stock here, just a review, safe AND effective. For population control.
Immediately after the experimental mRNA gene therapy COVID shots were rolled out… TV presenters, athletes, audience members & even comedians started collapsing on live TV every single day & no one questioned it.
Immediately after the experimental mRNA gene therapy COVID shots were rolled out… TV presenters, athletes, audience members & even comedians started collapsing on live TV every single day & no one questioned it. https://t.co/WlP3oAValk
— Valerie Anne Smith (@ValerieAnne1970) November 17, 2026
stock here: I have a pretty expensive HAM radio, haven’t used it yet, not certified. But this….is printed and by my machinery.




stock here: been kind of busy, so haven’t been able to address this issue.
++++++++++++++++ Summary, with full transcript below, 2.5 hours!
Why a Magnet Never Runs Out of Energy
EXPANDED SUMMARY | 27 chapters | Source: supplied narration (~2 hr 46 min)
1 The central puzzle: force is not energy
A refrigerator magnet may support paper against a steel door for decades, although it contains no battery, fuel, or electrical connection. The apparent paradox disappears when force is distinguished from work. Mechanical work requires a force acting through displacement; a stationary magnet supporting a stationary object performs no continuing work. The narration compares this with a table supporting a book and gravity maintaining an orbit. Muscles expend energy while holding an object because microscopic muscle fibers continually cycle; a conventional electromagnet consumes power principally through electrical resistance. A persistent current in a superconducting loop illustrates that a magnetic field can be maintained without resistive electrical loss.
2 Energy changes when objects move
A paperclip accelerating toward a magnet gains kinetic energy, but this is not evidence that the magnet is being consumed. The magnet–clip arrangement loses magnetic potential energy as it moves to a lower-energy configuration; impact then produces heat and sound. Pulling the clip away again takes external work and restores the higher-energy arrangement. Consequently, a closed cycle involving static permanent magnets yields no net free energy: permanent-magnet-only perpetual-motion machines cannot supply continual power. In motors and generators, magnets establish the field through which energy is converted, while electrical input, a turbine, wind, or another source supplies the usable energy. Magnetic fields themselves contain energy, but an unchanged static field is not a continuous energy output.
3 How magnetism was understood
The story begins with naturally magnetized lodestone and early Chinese compass use, including Shen Kuo’s description of magnetic declination. Petrus Peregrinus documented two poles and their attraction and repulsion; William Gilbert argued that Earth behaves like a magnet. In 1820, Ørsted linked electric current to magnetic deflection, and Ampère examined forces between current-carrying conductors. Faraday showed that changing magnetic flux induces electrical effects, enabling generators; Maxwell unified electricity, magnetism, and light as electromagnetic phenomena. The narration also explains magnetic fields as vector properties of space, illustrates them with iron filings, and notes that electric and magnetic fields are related by special relativity.
4 Poles, monopoles, and what experiments found
Breaking a bar magnet produces two smaller north–south dipoles, not isolated poles. The classical magnetic field has no beginning or end: Gauss’s law for magnetism states that net magnetic flux through any closed surface is zero. However, fundamental magnetic monopoles are not ruled out by every possible theory; Dirac’s 1931 argument connected their possible existence to quantization of electric charge, and later unification theories predicted extremely massive examples. The program recounts a single intriguing Stanford detector event in February 1982, without reproducible confirmation. It distinguishes hypothetical fundamental monopoles from effective, emergent monopole-like excitations in spin-ice materials and related laboratory systems.
5 The atomic explanation and magnetic materials
Magnetic moments originate largely in electrons’ intrinsic spin and, to a lesser extent in many solids, orbital motion. Electron spin is a quantum property, not literally a tiny ball rotating. Quantum energy levels explain why electrons in stable atoms do not continuously spiral inward or radiate energy away. Exchange interactions can favor aligned electron spins. In ferromagnets, many aligned atoms form magnetic domains; an initially unmagnetized sample can have differently oriented domains whose external effects cancel. Applying a strong field changes domain alignment. Permanent magnets retain that alignment because crystal structure, anisotropy, and defects resist reversal, whereas soft magnetic materials are engineered to magnetize and demagnetize readily.
6 Why real magnets sometimes weaken
“Never runs out of energy” does not mean “never demagnetizes.” Excessive temperature disrupts magnetic order, and above a material’s Curie temperature ferromagnetism disappears. Strong opposing fields, mechanical shock in susceptible magnets, corrosion, and slow domain rearrangement can also degrade performance. Material selection matters: the presentation contrasts ferrite, alnico, rare-earth magnets, and natural magnetic minerals, and discusses coercivity, remanence, and the role of manufacturing. Some geological rocks preserve remanent magnetism for billions of years under favorable conditions.
7 Wider applications and planetary context
The later chapters extend beyond permanent magnets to diamagnetism (including water’s very weak response), magnetic levitation, superconductivity, and prospective magnetic cooling. MRI relies on the magnetic behavior of hydrogen nuclei and radio-frequency signals rather than exposing tissue to ionizing X-rays. Earth’s field arises primarily from motion of conductive liquid metal in the outer core—the geodynamo—not from a permanently magnetized solid iron core. The narration covers magnetic reversals, changes in the terrestrial field, ancient Martian magnetism, auroras, and evidence that migratory birds and other animals use magnetic cues for orientation. Some proposed biological sensing mechanisms remain active research questions.
Bottom line A permanent magnet provides a durable magnetic field, not an inexhaustible energy supply. Forces can persist without continuous work; energy transfer occurs when a physical configuration changes, and the full system still obeys conservation of energy.
Editorial note: This expands and organizes the supplied presentation; it is not an independent scientific fact-check.
==============================
Why a Magnet Never Runs Out of Energy
FULL CLEANED VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT | 27 chapters | approximate runtime 2:46
Editing: Removed video timestamps, line-wrap artifacts, and interface text. All spoken words have been retained in their original order, including apparent transcription errors. Chapter headings are retained.
Chapter 1: The magnet mystery
Somewhere in your home, there is probably a small magnet holding a piece of paper to a steel door. It might be a shopping list, a photograph, or a child’s drawing. That magnet has no battery. It has no plug and no fuel. It has been pulling against the steel all day and all night, maybe for years, maybe for decades. On the last day, it will grip exactly as firmly as it did on the first. That should feel strange. Everything else we know that pushes or pulls for a long time eventually gets tired. Muscles burn. Batteries go flat. Engines need fuel. And even springs slowly relax. So, where is the magnet getting its strength from? Is there a hidden fuel tank inside it quietly draining away? Tonight, we’re going to follow that question all the way down through a surprising rule about force and energy through invisible fields that fill the space around us and into the strange quantum world of electrons inside iron where the real answer is waiting. Along the way, we’ll meet a puzzle that sounds almost silly.
Why can’t you cut a magnet in half and hold a lonely north pole in your hand? And we’ll visit a laboratory at Stanford where on one night in February 1982, a detector recorded something that has never happened again. We’ll also find out what really can make a magnet fade and why some rocks on Earth have been holding on to their magnetism for more than 3 billion years. There’s nothing you need to do now. Let your body settle and your breathing slow. Some of these ideas may surprise you and some may simply drift past like quiet thoughts at the edge of sleep. If these calm explorations help you rest, you can like the video and subscribe so others can find their way here, too. And now, let’s start with that small magnet on the door. A fridge magnet is weaker than you might think. At its surface, a typical flexible fridge magnet produces only a few thousandths of a Tesla. The Tesla is the unit scientists use to measure magnetic field strength, and a few thousandths of one is very little.
A hospital scanner, by comparison, works at more than a thousand times that strength. So, how does such a weak magnet hold paper against a door at all? Part of the answer is the steel. The door sits extremely close behind the magnet, and steel gathers and concentrates the field, giving the magnet something solid to grip. Take the same magnet and hold it a few centimeters away from the door, and its pull fades almost to nothing. The strength you feel is not just in the magnet. It lives in the partnership between magnet and metal, in that thin, quiet gap where the two almost touch. Many fridge magnets only stick on one side. If you’ve ever turned a flexible fridge magnet over, you may have noticed that the back grips firmly while the front barely sticks at all. That’s not an accident. Many of these magnets are made from a fine powder of ferite, a ceramic based on iron oxide mixed into rubber. During manufacture, the sheet is magnetized in narrow alternating stripes, north, south, north, south, running side by side.
That pattern sends most of the field out through the back face where it loops between neighboring stripes while very little escapes from the front. You can sometimes feel this for yourself. Slide two flexible magnets across each other, back to back, and they bump and catch in a gentle rhythm like a zipper of invisible ridges. A simple object quietly engineered so that all its strength faces the door. A magnet keeps working far away from Earth. You might wonder whether a magnet’s strength is borrowed from the planet somehow, the way a compass needle responds to Earth’s field. But a fridge magnet would hold paper just as well in orbit or deep in interplanetary space. Its field doesn’t come from Earth. It comes from the material itself, from the way countless tiny magnetic moments inside it have been lined up and locked in place. Astronauts on the International Space Station have used magnets to hold small items in place. Because in weightlessness, anything left loose simply floats away.
Out there, with no gravity pulling things down, a magnet’s grip becomes even more useful. Wherever you take it, it carries its own field along. A small invisible pattern that belongs to it alone. The first law
Chapter 2: Force vs. energy
of thermodynamics seems to say a magnet should run down. This law is one of the most trusted principles in all of physics. It says energy cannot be created or destroyed only changed from one form into another. Sunlight becomes sugar in a leaf. Sugar becomes motion in your muscles. Motion becomes heat in the brakes of a car. Energy is always accounted for, always moving from one place to another. So, it’s tempting to picture a magnet as a little energy store, a hidden tank slowly spending itself to keep that grip on the door. If that were true, every magnet would be on a countdown, weakening a little each day until the tank ran dry. But that’s not what we see. And the reason is not that the magnet breaks the law. It’s that we’ve misunderstood what the magnet is actually doing. The resolution comes in layers and the first layer is a lesson about the difference between force and energy. Holding still costs nothing at all. In physics, energy is transferred only when a force moves something through a distance.
Scientists call this quantity work. Push a box across the floor and you do work on it. Lift a book onto a shelf and you do work against gravity. But here is the key. If nothing moves, the distance is zero. And the work is zero, too. No matter how large the force, a force can be enormous and still spend no energy as long as nothing gives way. This sounds almost too simple, but it changes everything. A magnet holding a sheet of paper against a door is exerting a real force, but the paper isn’t moving. The magnet isn’t moving. And so, in the strict language of physics, no work is being done and no energy is being used. The magnet isn’t paying anything to hold on because holding on by itself has no price. A table holds up a book all year without getting tired. Think about an ordinary table with a heavy book resting on it. Gravity pulls the book downward and the table pushes back up with exactly the same force. It does this all day, all night, all year for as long as the book stays there.
Yet, nobody worries that the table will run out of energy. Its atoms simply resist being squeezed closer together. Nothing moves, and so nothing is spent. A magnet holding a paper clip is in exactly the same situation. There is a genuine force between them but no motion. And so the magnet transfers no energy to the clip. The table and the magnet are quiet partners in the same principle. They don’t strain. They don’t burn. They simply hold. Steady and patient. Because steady holding is something the universe allows for free. Earth has held the moon for billions of years without spending any fuel. The moon has been circling our planet for roughly 4 and a half billion years. All that time, Earth’s gravity has been pulling on it, bending its path into a loop around us. If force always cost energy, Earth would have needed some unimaginable gravitational fuel supply to keep this going. But it hasn’t used any. A field acting on an object is not the same thing as a process burning energy.
Gravity simply shapes the moon’s path moment by moment without being drained. The moon is slowly drifting outward. But that’s because of tides and the exchange of motion between Earth’s spin and the moon’s orbit. Not because gravity is getting tired. A magnet’s pull and Earth’s pull belong to the same family. fields that grip and guide and hold without a tank to empty. Your arms get tired for reasons that have nothing to do with physics. If holding still costs no energy, why does holding a heavy book at arms length make your muscles burn? The answer is hidden inside the muscle fibers themselves. Muscles don’t work like a rigid support. They’re built from tiny protein filaments that grab each other, pull, let go, and grab again over and over, many times every second. Even when your arm looks perfectly still, those filaments are constantly cycling, attaching, and detaching and reattaching. Each cycle burns a little chemical energy and releases a little heat.
So, your body is spending energy, but not on holding the book in the physics sense. It’s spending energy on the restless microscopic machinery it uses to stay rigid. A table doesn’t need that machinery. Neither does a magnet. Your tiredness is a story about biology, not about force. An ordinary electromagnet needs constant power for a similar reason. Wrap copper wire around an iron core, send electric current through the wire, and you get an electromagnet. Switch off the current and the magnetism disappears. So it might look as if electromagnets prove that magnetism needs a steady supply of energy. But look more closely at where that energy goes. Copper wire has electrical resistance. As current flows, electrons bump their way through the metal, and that friction turns electrical energy into heat. Hold your hand near a large electromagnet that has been running for a while and you’ll feel it warm. The power supply is not feeding the magnetic field itself. It’s replacing the energy lost as heat in the wire.
Like a muscle, an electromagnet spends energy staying switched on, not on the act of holding. A superconducting magnet reveals what magnetism really costs. Some materials when cooled to extremely low temperatures lose all electrical resistance. They become superconductors. If you start a current flowing around a closed loop of superconducting wire, something remarkable happens. You can disconnect the power supply entirely and the current keeps flowing on its own. No resistance means no heat and no heat means no loss. The magnetic field stays exactly where it is, steady and strong, just like a permanent magnet. This is the cleanest demonstration of all. Once friction is removed from the picture, a magnetic field costs nothing to maintain. The everyday intuition that force always needs fuel turns out to be a statement about muscles and resistive wires, not about forces themselves. Strip away the friction and the field simply stays. When a paperclip jumps to a magnet, it really does gain energy. So
Chapter 3: Energy and storage
far, we’ve talked about magnets holding things still. But what about the moment when a paperclip leaps across the table and clicks onto the magnet? That paperclip speeds up. It gains energy of motion and that energy is completely real. It has to come from somewhere. This is the point where the hidden fuel tank idea seems to return. Surely the magnet is spending a little of itself to throw the clip, but it isn’t. The energy isn’t withdrawn from inside the magnet at all. To understand where it comes from, we need to stop looking at the magnet alone and start looking at the whole arrangement. The magnet, the paperclip, and the field stretched between them. Energy, it turns out, doesn’t live in one object. It lives in the relationship. The energy belongs to the arrangement, not to the magnet. When the paperclip is far away from the magnet, the system of magnet, clip, and field holds a certain amount of stored energy. When the clip is close, the system holds less.
As the clip moves inward, the system slides from a higher energy arrangement to a lower energy one, and the difference shows up as motion. The magnet’s own internal order hasn’t changed. Nothing inside it has been used up. It’s a little like a marble rolling down into a bowl. The marble speeds up not because the bowl spent anything, but because the marble moved to a lower place. The magnetic field shapes the landscape and the paperclip rolls down into the valley of that landscape. When it clicks into place, the energy of that fall becomes a tiny sound and a tiny bit of warmth. And the magnet is exactly as strong as before. A falling ball follows exactly the same bookkeeping. Drop a ball from your hand and it speeds up as it falls. Where does that energy come from? Not from Earth spending fuel. Earth isn’t any weaker afterward. The ball speeds up because the system of Earth and ball has moved into a lower energy arrangement.
Physicists call the stored energy of the arrangement potential energy and the falling ball simply turns some of it into energy of motion. The paperclip and the magnet work the same way. The pull of the field converts stored potential energy into movement and nothing inside the magnet has to burn. Gravity and magnetism keep their accounts in the same calm way. Every bit of energy that appears as motion was already there, stored in the shape of things, waiting for something to move. Pulling the paperclip off puts all the energy back. Now imagine prying the paperclip away from the magnet again. You can feel the resistance as you pull. Your fingers are doing work and that work goes back into the system, raising it to its higher energy arrangement once more. The amount you put back is the same amount that was released when the clip snapped on. Let go and the clip leaps back toward the magnet. Pull it off again and you’ve paid the same price again. You can repeat this a million times and the magnet doesn’t weaken.
Each cycle is a loan borrowed and repaid in full. The magnet is not a spender at all. It’s more like a hill that stays put while you carry a stone up and let it roll down over and over again. The magnetic pull of a static magnet is what physicists call a conservative force. That word conservative has a special meaning here. A force is conservative when around any closed path, the energy it gives on one part of the journey, it takes back on another. Carry a paper clip in a loop around a magnet, starting and ending at the same spot, and the total energy the magnet gave you over the full loop is exactly zero. Some stretches speed the clip up, some slow it down, and in the end, everything cancels. Gravity behaves the same way. Climb a mountain and descend again by a different trail, and gravity’s books balance perfectly by the time you’re back where you started. This one property explains why a magnet can push and pull forever without running down.
Chapter 4: Permanent magnets
It never gives away anything it doesn’t eventually take back. No motor built only from permanent magnets has ever run by itself. For more than a century, inventors have tried to build machines powered by magnets alone. Wheels lined with magnets. Rotors chasing magnetic fields around a circle. Clever arrangements that look as if they should spin forever. Every single one of them stops. Somewhere around the circle, there is always a sticking point, a position where the forces balance and the rotor settles to rest. That isn’t bad luck or poor engineering. It’s the conservative nature of the magnetic force at work. Around any full loop, the magnets give back exactly as much energy as they take. So there is no surplus left over to keep anything turning. Add a little friction and the wheel slows and stops. These machines have never worked. And the reason is the same quiet rule that keeps the fridge magnet from running down. Pulling soft iron toward a magnet wastess a tiny bit of energy, but not the magnets.
When a piece of soft iron is drawn toward a magnet, something happens inside the iron. Its own internal magnetic regions shift and rearrange to line up with the field. That rearranging isn’t perfectly smooth, and a small amount of energy is lost as heat. So, there is a real loss in the process. But this loss is paid for by the motion and by the stored energy of the arrangement, not by the permanent magnets’s internal order. The magnet’s alignment stays locked in place while the iron does its shuffling. It’s a little like a dance partner who stays perfectly steady while the other partner stumbles. The stumble costs something, but the steady partner hasn’t lost a thing. Power stations use magnets, but the energy comes from somewhere else. Inside the generators of most power stations, magnets spin inside coils of wire or coils spin inside magnetic fields. That motion produces electricity which flows out into cities, homes, and the lights you may have just switched , 1 secondoff.
It’s easy to imagine that the magnets are the source of all that energy, but they aren’t. The energy comes from whatever turns the shaft. Steam from burning fuel or from a nuclear reactor. Falling water in a dam. Wind pushing on the blades of a turbine. Stop the steam and the generator stops. No matter how strong its magnets are. The magnets simply shape how motion is converted into electricity. They are the guides, not the fuel. And they can do that job for decades without wearing out. Electric motors use the same idea in reverse. In a generator, motion becomes electricity. In a motor, electricity becomes motion. The fan cooling a bedroom, the drum of a washing machine, the wheels of an electric car, all of them are turned by electric motors, and many of those motors contain permanent magnets. Electrical energy flows in, interacts with the magnets fields, and comes out as rotation. Once again, the magnets don’t supply the energy. They provide the steady field that the electricity pushes against.
That’s why the permanent magnets inside such a motor can keep working for many years without weakening. They’re not being consumed. They’re more like the riverbed than the river, shaping the flow of energy without being washed away by it. A magnetic field does store energy, but only a fixed amount. There’s a subtle point worth resting on. The field around a magnet does hold energy. Physicists can calculate exactly how much the energy stored in a magnetic field grows with the square of the field strength. So doubling the field quadruples the energy. A field of one Tesla stores roughly 400 K in every cubic meter of space. The weak field near a fridge magnet stores only a few jewels per cubic meter. A tiny amount. But here is the important part. That energy just sits there. It isn’t leaking away or being spent on holding the paper. It’s a fixed store like water in a sealed jar. It only changes when the arrangement changes. When something moves closer or farther away. Left alone, the field and its energy simply remain quiet and unchanged.
Magnetism
Chapter 5: History of magnetism
began with a stone that pulls iron. Long before anyone wrote equations about fields, people noticed something strange about certain rocks. A dark stone called load stone could pull iron objects toward it with no rubbing, no heating, and no preparation at all. Load stone is a naturally magnetized form of magnetite, an iron mineral. Hold a piece of it near an iron nail, and the nail slides toward it as if called. To ancient observers, this must have looked almost alive. Most stones simply lie where you put them. This one reached out across empty air and moved metal. Load stone was the first permanent magnet humans ever held. And in a sense, it had already been answering tonight’s question for thousands of years. It never needed feeding. It simply pulled patiently for as long as anyone kept it. The word magnet may come from a region in ancient Greece. The name is usually traced to magnesia, a region associated with ancient Greek sources of these unusual stones. Greek thinkers puzzled over them.
The philosopher Thales who lived around 600 years before the common era is said to have suggested that load stone must possess a kind of soul because it could move iron. In his time, movement was closely tied to life. , 1 secondRivers flowed, animals walked, plants turned toward the sun. A stone that could move another object seemed to share in that quality. Today, we know there’s no soul inside a load stone. But in a way, Thales had noticed something real. The stone was doing something without being pushed, without being fed, without any visible cause. It would take more than 2,000 years to explain what that something was. Lightning may have magnetized some of the first magnets. Loadstones aren’t made in workshops. They become magnetized out in nature. And scientists have wondered for a long time how ordinary magnetite is common, but most of it isn’t strongly magnetized. One leading idea is that lightning did the work. A lightning strike carries a brief but enormous electric current.
And as we’ll see later, electric currents create magnetic fields. When lightning hits the ground near magnetite, that sudden surge of magnetic field may be strong enough to line up the mineral’s internal magnetism and lock it in place. If this is right, then some of the oldest magnets humans ever found were made in a fraction of a second in the flash of a storm and then held their magnetism quietly for centuries afterward, waiting in the ground to be picked up. In China, load stone was first used for divination. Before anyone used magnets to find their way, they used them to look for meaning. In ancient China, load stone devices appear in the context of divination and geommancy, the practice of arranging buildings and spaces in harmony with the land. There are claims of very early southpointing spoons from the Han period. Spoon-shaped pieces of load stone that would turn on a smooth board until they pointed south. Historians still debate how early these devices really were and how they were used.
What seems clear is that the strange pointing behavior of magnetized stone was noticed and valued long before it became a tool for travel. People saw a stone that always turned the same way and they wondered what it was trying to tell them. The first clear description of a magnetized needle comes from Shen Quo in 1088. Shen Kuo was a Chinese scholar who wrote about an astonishing range of subjects from astronomy to mathematics to geology. In 1088, he described a needle that had been magnetized by rubbing it on load stone and how it could be used to indicate direction. He also noticed something subtle. The needle didn’t point exactly to true north. It pointed slightly to one side. This was an early recognition of what is now called magnetic declination, the difference between magnetic north and geographic north. Navigators today still have to correct for it. Shen Quo saw nearly a thousand years ago that Earth’s magnetic directions and its geographic directions are not quite the same.
A small observation that turned out to hold a very large truth. The compass took to the sea about 900 years ago. Earliest clear record of a compass being used for navigation at sea dates to around 1111 to 1117 in China. Sailors could now find their direction even when clouds hid the sun and stars. In Europe, a scholar named Alexander Nekham described sailors using a magnetized needle around 1190. Picture what that meant on a dark overcast night far from land. No coastline, no stars, only waves in every direction. And yet a small sliver of magnetized iron floating or balanced on a pin would quietly turn and settle, pointing the way. It asked for nothing. It needed no fuel. It simply responded to an invisible pattern that wrapped the entire planet. A pattern no one at the time could explain. In 1269, a French scholar wrote one of the first careful studies of magnets. His name was
Chapter 6: Understanding fields
Petrus Peragrinus, sometimes called Peter the Pilgrim. He wrote a letter describing experiments with load stone and it reads in places almost like modern science. He described how a magnet has two poles. He showed that like poles repel each other and unlike poles attract. And he noticed something curious. If you break a magnet, you don’t get one piece with only a north pole and another with only a south. You get two complete magnets, each with its own pair of poles. Peragrinus couldn’t explain why that puzzle would wait more than seven centuries for its deepest , 1 secondanswer. But he saw it clearly, and he wrote it down. A small mystery tucked into a medieval letter, waiting quietly for physics to catch up. William Gilbert built a little earth to understand magnetism. In 1600, the English physician William Gilbert published a book called De Magnete, the result of years of patient experiments. One of his favorite tools was a small sphere carved from load stone. He called it a terrella, which means little earth.
Gilbert moved tiny compass needles across the surface of his terella and watched how they behaved. Near the middle, they lay flat. Near the ends, they tilted and dipped toward the surface. He realized that real compass needles on the real Earth do exactly the same thing. Lying flatter near the equator and dipping more steeply toward the poles. His little stone ball sitting on a table was behaving like a miniature version of the whole planet. Gilbert concluded that Earth itself is a giant magnet. Before Gilbert, people offered all sorts of explanations for why compass needles point north. Some thought the needle was drawn toward the pole star. Others imagined a great magnetic mountain somewhere in the far north, pulling every needle toward it. Gilbert’s experiments with his terella led him to a boulder idea. The compass points north because earth itself behaves like a magnet.
He also drew a careful line between two kinds of attraction that people had often confused. the pull of a magnet and the pull of amber rubbed with cloth, which we now know is static electricity. Gilbert was right that Earth is magnetic. Though, as we’ll see later tonight, the reason turns out to be stranger than a giant buried load stone. The planet’s magnetism is not frozen in place. It flows. In 1820, a compass
Chapter 7: Electricity and fields
needle twitched next to a wire. The Danish physicist Hans Christian Orststead was working with an electric current flowing through a wire. Nearby sat a compass. When the current flowed, the compass needle moved. When the current stopped, it settled back. It was a small motion, but it changed everything. Until then, electricity and magnetism had seemed like separate subjects, two different mysteries. Orstead’s twitching needle showed that an electric current creates magnetism. Moving charge produces a magnetic field around it. In that one moment, two branches of physics began to grow together into one. And it hinted at something deeper still, that the magnetism of a load stone and the magnetism around a wire might at their root be the same thing. Two wires carrying current can pull toward each other. Within weeks of hearing about Orstead’s discovery, the French physicist Andre Marie Aair was running experiments of his own. He set up two parallel wires and sent current through both.
When the currents flowed in the same direction, the wires drew together. When the currents flowed in opposite directions, the wires pushed apart. No magnets were involved at all. Only electricity in motion. Ampair had shown that currents don’t just affect compass needles. They affect each other, attracting and repelling just like the poles of a magnet. It was as if the wires themselves had become magnets simply because charge was flowing through them. The line between electricity and magnetism was growing thinner by the week. Ampair guessed that magnets are full of tiny circling currents. Ampair then made a bold leap. If currents in wires behave like magnets, maybe magnets are secretly full of currents. He imagined that every piece of magnetized material might contain countless tiny loops of circulating current, all lined up in the same direction, adding together to produce the magnets’s field. At the time, nobody knew that atoms contain electrons. Nobody knew what electric charge was made of.
Ampair’s guess was remarkably close to the truth. Part of a material’s magnetism really does come from electrons moving in tiny loops inside atoms. The other part comes from something Ampere couldn’t have imagined. A built-in property of the electron itself. We’ll arrive at that a little later. For now, it’s enough to notice how far one careful guess traveled. Michael Faraday discovered that a changing magnetic field makes electricity. Faraday was the son of a blacksmith and had very little formal schooling. He started work as a bookbinder apprentice and taught himself science by reading the books he was binding. In 1831, he discovered electromagnetic induction. When a magnetic field changes by a magnet moving near a coil or by a current switching on and off, it creates an electric current in the coil. Orstead had shown that electricity makes magnetism. Faraday showed that magnetism when it changes makes electricity. This is the principle behind every power station generator on Earth. Notice the word changing.
A magnet sitting perfectly still beside a coil produces no current at all. Only motion, only change turns the field into flowing energy. Faraday imagined the space around a magnet filled with lines of force. Scatter iron filings on a sheet of paper over a magnet. Tap the paper gently and the filings arrange themselves into curving lines looping from one end of the magnet to the other. , 1 secondFaraday studied these patterns closely. He began to think of the space around a magnet not as empty, but as filled with lines of force, something real stretching through the air. Most scientists of his time thought of forces as acting directly across empty distance with nothing in between. Faraday gradually developed a different view that the field itself is something physically real, a condition of space that exists whether or not anything is there to feel it. That idea born from iron filings on paper became one of the deepest ideas in all of physics. James Clerk Maxwell discovered that light is made of electricity and magnetism.
Faraday had pictures, but not much mathematics. In the 1860s, the Scottish physicist James Clerk Maxwell turned those pictures into equations. When he combined everything that was known about electric and magnetic fields, he found something astonishing. Changing electric fields create magnetic fields, and changing magnetic fields create electric fields. Together they can chase each other through space as a wave. When Maxwell calculated how fast that wave should travel, the answer matched the speed of light. Light itself, he realized, is an electromagnetic wave. The glow of a candle, the warmth of sunlight, the stars in the night sky, all of it is electricity and magnetism weaving together and racing across space. Maxwell’s equations were not always four elegant lines. Today, students learn Maxwell’s equations as four compact statements, often printed on posters and t-shirts. But Maxwell’s original theory contained around 20 equations written in a more cumbersome form.
In the 1880s, the English physicist Oliver Heavyside and others reworked the theory and condensed it into the four equations that carry Maxwell’s name today. Heavyside like Faraday was largely self-taught. The result was one of the most beautiful summaries in science. Four short lines describe how electric charges create fields, how changing fields create each other, and one more line that will matter a great deal later tonight. A line saying that magnetic field lines never begin or end anywhere. Hold on to that one. It’s the key to a puzzle we’ll reach soon. Magnetism turns out to be closely tied to relativity.
Chapter 8: Relativity and space
One of the most surprising insights of modern physics is that magnetism and electricity are not truly separate forces. They’re two faces of one electromagnetic force. And which face you see depends on how you’re moving. Picture two wires carrying current. From one point of view, the wires attract because of magnetism. But according to Einstein’s special relativity, an observer moving along with the electrons would see the situation differently. Lengths along the direction of motion change slightly, and the balance of positive and negative charge in each wire appears to shift. From that moving point of view, the attraction can be understood as ordinary electric attraction. Magnetism in this sense is what electric forces look like when charges are in motion. Electrons in a wire move astonishingly slowly. When you flip a light switch, the light comes on almost instantly. So, it’s natural to assume that electrons race through the wire.
In fact, electrons drift through a copper wire at typically less than a millimeter/ second, slower than a snail. The signal travels fast, but the electrons themselves barely creep along. That makes the relativistic explanation of magnetism even more remarkable. The effect of relativity at such slow speeds is incredibly tiny. And yet, magnetism between wires is easily noticeable. The reason is numbers. A wire contains an enormous number of charges, and their tiny effects add up. A slow drift multiplied across countless electrons becomes a force you can feel in your hands. A magnetic field is a property of the space around a magnet. So what exactly is a field? Imagine placing a tiny compass needle at any point near a magnet. At each point, the needle would settle in a particular direction and it would feel a particular strength of pull. A magnetic field is simply that pair of facts, a strength and a direction assigned to every point in space. It isn’t a substance like air or water.
It’s more like the slope of a hillside, a property of each place, telling anything that responds to magnetism which way to turn and how strongly. Near the magnet, the field is strong. Farther away, it weakens and it fills the space whether or not a compass is there to notice. The air around a fridge magnet looks empty, but it’s quietly patterned. Every point holding its own small direction. Field lines are a way of drawing something invisible. Scientists picture magnetic fields with curved lines like the patterns iron filings make. These field lines follow the direction a compass would point. Where they crowd closely together, the field is strong. Where they spread apart, the field is weaker. Near the poles of a bar magnet, the lines bunch tightly. Out at the sides, they arc wide and loose. Field lines also never cross each other. If they did, a compass sitting at the crossing would have to point in two directions at once, which makes no sense. Of course, the lines aren’t physical threads stretched through space.
The field is smooth and continuous. The lines are simply a map, a gentle way for human eyes to see a pattern that has no color and no shape of its own. Iron filings reveal the field, but they also change it. When you sprinkle iron filings around a magnet, each tiny filing becomes magnetized and lines up with the field. That’s what makes the pattern visible. But there’s a subtle catch. Because each filing becomes a tiny magnet, it adds its own small field to the pattern. The filings cluster into lines partly because they attract each other end to end like beads joining on a string. The real field is smooth and continuous. The filings break it into distinct strands. So, the beautiful pattern on the paper is a good guide, but not a perfect portrait. It’s a reminder that in physics, observing something often means touching it, and touching it changes it, even if only a little. Magnetic fields come in an enormous range of strengths. Scientists measure field strength in Tesla.
Earth’s magnetic field at the surface is very gentle, ranging from roughly 25 to 65 millionths of a Tesla, depending on where you stand. A fridge magnet’s surface field is a few thousandth of a Tesla, about 100 times stronger than Earth’s. A hospital MRI scanner usually works at about 1 and a half to three Tesla, thousands of times stronger still. And as we’ll see later, there are laboratory magnets and dead stars that go far, far beyond that. It’s a vast ladder. At the bottom, the whisper of Earth’s field, enough to turn a compass needle. Higher up, the steady grip of a magnet on a door. Higher still, fields strong enough to make a living creature float. Every magnetic field line closes on itself in a loop. Outside a bar magnet, field lines run from the north pole around to the south pole, arcing through the surrounding space, but they don’t stop at the south pole. Inside the material, they continue onward, running from south back to north.
So, every line forms a complete closed loop passing out through the air and back in through the magnet. This is very different from how electric fields behave around a charged object where field lines start on positive charges and end on negative ones. Magnetic lines have no starting point and no ending point. They simply circle around and through endlessly. Keep this picture of closed loops in mind because it’s about to explain why you can never hold a single magnetic , 1 secondpole in your hand. Magnetism can push and pull and it can steer. Gravity only ever pulls. Everything with mass attracts everything else. Magnetism is richer. Two magnets can attract or repel depending on how they’re turned. And there’s something even stranger about how magnetism acts on moving charged particles. The magnetic force on a moving charge always acts sideways to its motion at right angles to the direction it’s traveling. A sideways push like that can’t speed a particle up or slow it down. It can only bend its path.
That’s why charged particles in a magnetic field often move in circles or spirals. The field steers them without giving them energy. Like a gentle hand on a shoulder turning someone without pushing them forward. Even here, magnetism guides without spending. A magnetic field that doesn’t change sends no energy away. A radio antenna needs constant power to work. It has to keep pushing electric charges back and forth so that changing fields can radiate outward as radio waves, carrying energy away into the world. A static magnet is completely different. Its field doesn’t change in time. So, it sends out no waves at all. Only changing or oscillating fields radiate. This is another quiet reason a magnet doesn’t run down. If its field were constantly streaming energy outward like a radio signal, it would have to be replenished from somewhere. But a steady field just sits in place. There is nothing flowing away from it, nothing being lost to the distance. A magnet doesn’t broadcast. It simply is.
A permanent magnet’s field is a frozen pattern in space. Put everything together and a clear picture emerges. A permanent magnet’s field is a
Chapter 9: Magnetic poles
, 1 secondfixed shape, a pattern of strengths and directions surrounding the magnet. It stores a certain amount of energy and that energy stays put as long as nothing in the arrangement changes. It sends nothing away. It spends nothing on holding objects still. When objects move in the field, energy shifts between motion and storage, and every loan is eventually repaid. So, the first part of the mystery is solved. A magnet never runs out of energy because it was never spending any. But that still leaves a deeper question. Where does the field come from in the first place? And what keeps it there? To answer that, we’ll need to go inside the magnet. And the first clue comes from trying to cut one in half. Cut a magnet in half and you get two complete magnets. Take a bar magnet with a north pole at one end and a south pole at the other. Now cut it across the middle. You might expect to end up holding a lonely north pole in one hand and a lonely south pole in the other. But that’s not what happens.
The moment you cut it, a new pair of poles appears at the cut. The half that was the north end now has a fresh south pole on its cut face. The half that was the south end now has a fresh north pole. You’re holding two complete smaller magnets, each with both poles. This is exactly what Petrus Peragrinus described in 1269. It seems almost like a trick as if the magnet refuses to be divided into its parts. And in a sense, that’s exactly what it’s doing. You can keep cutting forever and never find a single pole. Cut the halves again and again. You get complete magnets. Keep going, slicing smaller and smaller until the magnet is ground into fine powder. Every grain of that powder, if it still holds its magnetism, is a tiny magnet with a north end and a south end. Look deeper at the level of single atoms and the pattern continues. Each magnetic atom behaves like a tiny two-ended magnet. Look deeper still at a single electron and even there the magnetism comes with two ends. No matter how small you go, the north and south refuse to separate.
It’s a remarkable fact about our universe. Of all the many things nature lets us divide, the two ends of a magnet are among the few that always stay together. Electric charge doesn’t behave this way at all. Rub a balloon on your hair and the balloon picks up a surplus of negative charge. It can stick to a wall all on its own with no matching positive charge attached to it. And a single electron is an isolated negative charge complete by itself. In electricity, positive and negative can be pulled , 1 secondapart and kept apart. This is what makes the magnetic situation so striking. Electricity has individual charges, the starting and ending points for electric field lines. Magnetism, as far as anyone has ever confirmed, has no such thing. There is no magnetic equivalent of a lone electron. No particle that is purely north or purely south. Two forces that are deeply connected. And yet they differ in this one fundamental way. Physicists capture the difference with a rule about closed surfaces.
Imagine wrapping an invisible bubble around an electric charge. more electric field lines would leave the bubble than enter it because the charge is a source sending lines outward. The number of lines escaping tells you how much charge is inside. Now wrap a bubble around anything magnetic. A bar magnet, a single atom, anything at all. Exactly as many magnetic field lines enter the bubble as leave it. Every line that goes out comes back in somewhere else. There’s no surplus, no source, no sink. However you shape the bubble and wherever you put it, the count always balances. This simple rule about bubbles and lines is one of the most important statements in all of physics. That rule is called Gaus’s law for magnetism. It’s the line in Maxwell’s equations we flagged earlier. It says the total magnetic flux through any closed surface is zero. Flux is just a measure of how much field passes through a surface. Lines going out counted one way, lines coming in counted the other.
Zero total means every outgoing line is matched by an incoming one. In plain language, it says there are no magnetic charges for field lines to start or end on. There’s nothing magnetic that acts as a pure source the way an electron acts as a source of electric field. Every magnetic field line must close on itself, which is exactly the picture of loops we saw earlier. One short equation and the
Chapter 10: Magnetic monopoles
mystery of the unsplitable magnet is written right into the foundations of electromagnetism. The poles are not substances stored at the ends of a magnet. It’s easy to imagine that the north and south poles are two kinds of stuff packed into opposite ends of a bar, but they’re not. The poles are simply the places where the closed loops of field leave the material and re-enter it. North is where the lines come out. South is where they go back in. Nothing special sits there. It’s a little like a rubber band. A rubber band has no ends at all, but cut it and you instantly have two ends created by the cut itself. Cut a magnet and the field rearranges so that lines leave and re-enter at the fresh faces , 1 secondand two new poles appear. The poles were never things. They were always just the doorways of the loops. The deep reason lies in loops of charge and spinning electrons. Why are there no magnetic charges in ordinary matter? Because magnetism in matter comes from two sources and both of them are naturally two-ended.
The first is moving charge going around in loops like electrons circling inside atoms. Any loop of current produces a field with a north side and a south side. And you can’t have one side without the other. The second source is a built-in property of the electron called spin, which we’ll explore soon. Spin also behaves like a tiny two-ended magnet that can’t be split. Physicists call such two-ended magnets dipoles. Everything magnetic around us is built from dipoles stacked together. And because the smallest pieces are already dipoles, cutting will never separate north from south. You can only divide the stack. Each half of a cut magnet is weaker than the original. The two magnets you get after cutting are both complete, but neither is as strong as the whole. Each contains only half of the aligned magnetic material. So each produces a smaller overall field. There’s also a subtler effect. A magnet’s own field looping around from north to south tends to work against its internal alignment. Trying to undo it.
Physicists call this selfdemagnetization. A long slender magnet suffers very little from it because its poles are far apart. A short stubby piece suffers more because its poles are close together and its own field pushes back harder. So cutting a magnet into many small chunks can leave each piece not only smaller but a little more fragile, more easily coaxed out of its alignment. Cutting a magnet only partway rearranges its field. What if you cut a notch halfway through a bar magnet and stop there? The magnet doesn’t become two magnets because the uncut part still connects the two halves. Instead, the field rearranges itself around the notch. New pole regions form on the faces of the gap with field lines jumping across the empty space from one side of the cut to the other while the remaining bridge of material still carries the field through. It’s a little like a river meeting a rock. Some of the water flows around through the remaining channel and some spills across.
The field always finds a way to close its loops, adjusting smoothly to whatever shape you give it. And that leaves us with a lingering question. Is it truly impossible to find a lone magnetic pole? Or have we simply never found one? Nothing in the equations actually forbids a single magnetic pole. This is a subtle and beautiful point. Gaus’s law for magnetism says the total magnetic flux through any closed surface is zero. But that zero isn’t there because someone proved monopoles are impossible. It’s there because no magnetic monopole, a particle carrying a single north or south pole, has ever been confirmed. If one were discovered tomorrow, physicists could simply add a magnetic charge to Maxwell’s equations, and the equations would become even more symmetrical with electricity and magnetism mirroring each other perfectly. Some physicists find that symmetry so appealing that they suspect monopoles must exist somewhere. So, the zero in that equation is less like a wall and more like an empty chair. Nobody has sat there yet.
But the chair has been waiting for nearly a century. In 1931, Paul Durac showed that one monopole would explain a deep
Chapter 11: The hunt for monopoles
mystery. Every electron in the universe carries exactly the same electric charge. Every proton carries the same charge in the opposite direction. Electric charge comes in neat whole number steps, never in fractions of these units in free particles. But why? Nothing in ordinary physics demanded it. The English physicist Paul Durac found a remarkable connection. If even one magnetic monopole existed anywhere in the universe, the rules of quantum mechanics would require all electric charges to come in whole number multiples of a basic unit. A single monopole somewhere perhaps far across the cosmos would explain why every electron is identical in charge. It was an extraordinary idea. The existence of one strange particle might be written into the charge of every atom in your body. Some theories predict monopoles automatically. In 1974, the Dutch physicist Gerard Tuft and the Russian physicist Alexander Polakov independently made a striking discovery.
Certain theories that try to unify the fundamental forces of nature predict magnetic monopoles without anyone putting them in by hand. In these theories, monopoles appear naturally as stable knots in the fields that filled the very early universe. Twists that can’t be untwisted once they form. They wouldn’t be simple point particles like electrons. They’d be tiny, intricate structures, frozen leftovers from the universe’s first moments. Suddenly, monopoles weren’t just an elegant possibility. They looked like something the early universe might have produced as a matter of course, which made their absence even more puzzling. These monopoles would be almost unimaginably heavy. The monopoles predicted by unified theories wouldn’t be light, nimble particles. Estimates put their mass at around 10,000 trillion times the mass of a proton. A single particle smaller than an atom carrying the mass of a small bacterium. Nothing like that could ever be created in a particle accelerator.
The energy needed is far beyond the reach of any machine humans have built or are likely to build. If such monopoles exist, the only place they could have been made is the early universe itself. in the intense heat just after the Big Bang. Any that survived would be ancient relics drifting slowly through space for nearly 14 billion years, perhaps passing through Earth from time to time, unseen and almost impossible to catch. The missing monopoles helped inspire one of cosmologyy’s biggest ideas. If the early universe naturally produced monopoles, calculations suggested it should have made a great many of them. So many that they should be fairly common today, perhaps even dominating the mass of the universe. But no one sees them. This contradiction became known as the monopole problem. One of the motivations behind the theory of cosmic inflation was to solve it. Inflation proposes that in its first fraction of a second, the universe expanded at an extraordinary rate.
If that happened after the monopoles formed, any such relics would have been spread so thinly across space that we might never encounter even one. So the empty chair in Maxwell’s equations is connected to the largest question of all, how the universe itself began. On Valentine’s Day 1982, a detector recorded a single strange event. At Stanford University, the , 1 secondphysicist Blas Cabrera had built a detector made of a superconducting loop of wire. If a magnetic monopole passed through the loop, it would cause a sudden jump in the current, a jump of a very specific size, exactly what a single magnetic charge should produce. On the 14th of February 1982, the detector recorded exactly such a jump. It matched the prediction for a passing monopole perfectly. It was thrilling. But then came the waiting. Cabrera and others built larger and more sensitive detectors. No second event was ever seen. To this day, that single signal remains unexplained and unconfirmed. Was it a visitor from the early universe or some unknown disturbance?
Nobody knows. It stands alone in the records. One quiet jump on one February night, never repeated. Giant detectors have searched for monopoles underground and under ice. After Cabrera’s event, physicists built ever larger experiments to catch a passing monopole. In the 1990s, the macro experiment deep under a mountain in Italy, watched for slow, heavy particles crossing its detectors. Later, the ice cube detector at the South Pole, a cubic kilometer of Antarctic ice threaded with light sensors, joined the search. A monopole moving through the ice would leave a distinctive trail of light. None of these experiments has found one. Instead, they’ve set very strict upper limits on how many monopoles could be passing through Earth. If ancient monopoles exist at all, they must be extraordinarily rare. The chair remains empty even after we built rooms the size of mountains to look for whoever might sit in it. At the Large Hadron Collider, an experiment tries to trap monopoles.
At CERN, the European laboratory near Geneva, an experiment called Moal hunts for lighter monopoles that might be created when particles collide at enormous energies. Its detectors are surprisingly simple. Plastic sheets would record the damage trail of a heavily charged particle passing through, and blocks of aluminium are designed to trap monopoles inside them. Later, scientists scanned those blocks with ultra sensitive instruments to look for any trapped magnetic charge. By 2024, Moal had ruled out monopoles lighter than nearly 4 trillion electron volts across a range of magnetic charges. Separate searches using collisions of lead ions excluded some light monopoles that could be created in the intense magnetic fields of near mississ collisions. Again and again, the traps come back empty. The search for a magnetic monopole is still going on. As of late 2026, no fundamental magnetic monopole has ever been confirmed.
The hunt continues with upgraded MOA doll detectors running during the current period of collisions at the Large Hadron Collider. Physicists keep watching, keep scanning, keep refining their traps. It’s one of the longest open searches in physics, stretching back to Draq in 1931. And whether a monopole is ever found or not, the search has already taught us a great deal about unified forces, about the early universe, about the structure of electromagnetism.
Chapter 12: Emergent phenomena
Meanwhile, nature has offered physicists something unexpected. Not a true monopole, but something that behaves remarkably like one hiding inside an ordinarylooking crystal. Some crystals contain something called spin ice. In certain crystals, such as dprosium titanate, the atomic magnets sit on a lattice made of tiny tetrahedra, little pyramids with four corners. Each atomic magnet sits on a corner shared between two pyramids and points either into one pyramid or out of it. At low temperatures, they settle into a pattern where every pyramid has two magnets pointing in and two pointing out. This rule turns out to be mathematically similar to the arrangement of hydrogen atoms in ordinary water ice, which is how these materials got their name, spin ice. It’s a strange and delicate kind of order, one that can never be perfectly settled. There are countless ways to satisfy the twoin two out rule and the crystal keeps a quiet restlessness even near absolute zero. In 2008, theorists predicted magnetic charges inside spin ice.
The theorists Cladio Castelnovo, Roderick Mosner and Shivaji Sundi asked what happens when the two in two out rule is broken. Suppose one atomic magnet flips. Then one pyramid has three magnets pointing in and one out while its neighbor has one in and three out. They realized that these defects should behave like free north and south magnetic charges. Even more surprising, the two defects could wander apart as more magnets flipped one after another along a chain, carrying the magnetic charges away from each other through the crystal. A pair of separated magnetic charges moving independently inside a solid. It sounded almost too good to be true, like a monopole conjured out of ordinary matter. In 2009, experiments supported the picture. Several research teams set out to test the prediction. One team used beams of neutrons which carry a tiny magnetism of their own and can sense the arrangement of atomic magnets inside a crystal. They saw strings of flipped spins connecting the defects just as the theory described.
Another team used particles called muons to measure a flow of these magnetic charges through the material. They called it magnetricity. A magnetic version of electricity with magnetic charges drifting through a crystal much as electric charges drift through a wire. For the first time, something behaving like magnetic charge had been seen moving inside a real material. Not in a theory or on a blackboard, but in a laboratory sample sitting on a bench. Spin ice monopoles only appear in the deep cold. These magnetic charges don’t show up at room temperature. They appear at temperatures only a few degrees above absolute zero, the coldest possible temperature, where the jiggling of atoms nearly stops. In that frozen stillness, the defects can form and travel through the crystal, moving much like ions moving through a liquid. warm the crystal even slightly and the delicate order dissolves, the defects blurring into general disorder.
So these monopoles live in a very special world, a world of extreme cold and careful conditions, quiet enough for subtle collective behavior to emerge. It’s a reminder that matter can do surprising things when everything else falls still. Scientists built a durac monopole in a cloud of ultra cold atoms. In 2014, researchers took a different approach. They worked with a cloud of rubidium atoms cooled to within a tiny fraction of a degree above absolute zero. At such temperatures, the atoms behave together as a single quantum object. By carefully controlling magnetic fields around the cloud, the researchers engineered what is called a synthetic magnetic field, one that acts on the atoms in the same way a real magnetic field would act on electrons. Within that synthetic field, they created a quantum analog of a DAC monopole, the very structure Paul Drack had imagined in 1931.
It wasn’t a true monopole floating through space, but it let physicists see for the first time the mathematical shape Drack had described made real in a cloud of atoms. These monopoles are emergent, and they don’t break the
Chapter 13: Atomic magnetism
rules. Both the spin ice monopoles and the rubidium monopole are what physicists call emergent. They’re collective patterns made from many ordinary parts working together. If you could look inside a spin ice monopole, you’d find only normal electrons and atoms. Each one an ordinary two-ended magnet. The magnetic charge exists in the pattern, not in any single particle. It’s a little like a wave moving across a field of wheat. The wave is real. You can watch it travel, but there’s no single stalk of wheat that is the wave. So, these discoveries don’t overturn Gaus’s law. Fundamental magnetic poles still come in pairs. What has emerged is a new kind of behavior born from crowds of atoms acting together. Emergent monopoles are still scientifically valuable. Even though they aren’t fundamental particles, these monopoles matter. They give physicists a way to test the mathematics of magnetic charge in the laboratory. studying how such charges move, interact, and behave.
Theories that once lived only on paper can now be checked against real measurements. And researchers are curious whether these effects might one day be useful in new kinds of magnetic devices, perhaps carrying information as magnetic charge instead of electric charge. The search for a true monopole continues out in the cosmos and inside particle colliders. Meanwhile, these crystal monopoles offer a quieter kind of discovery, and they lead us naturally toward the real source of all ordinary magnetism. The electrons inside every atom. An electron moving around a nucleus is a tiny magnet. Remember Ampair’s guess that magnets are full of tiny circulating currents. Inside an atom, electrons are bound around a positively charged nucleus. In a simple picture, an electron moving around the nucleus is a tiny loop of moving charge. Like any loop of current, it produces a small magnetic field with a north side and a south side. Physicists call this the electron’s orbital magnetic moment.
Moment here simply means a measure of magnetic strength and direction. As we’ll see, the true picture of an electron in an atom is stranger than a little planet circling a sun. But the essential idea holds. When charge moves in loops inside an atom, magnetism appears. Ampair was right. Nearly a century before anyone could prove it. The natural unit of atomic magnetism is called the bore magneton. Atomic magnets are almost unimaginably small. Physicists measure them using a unit called the bore magneton, named after the Danish physicist Neils Boore. One bore magneton is about 9.27 * 10us4 Jew per Tesla. Written out, that’s a decimal point followed by 23 zeros before the first meaningful digit. It’s so small that a single atomic magnet could never be felt by any human hand. To make a magnetic field strong enough to hold a sheet of paper to a door, you need trillions upon trillions of these tiny magnets, all lined up and pointing the same way. The steady grip of a fridge magnet is the combined voice of an almost countless crowd.
In 1922, a beam of silver atoms split in two. In Frankfurt, the physicists Ottoarn and Valter Gerlock sent a beam of silver atoms through a magnetic field that was stronger on one side than the other. Each silver atom behaves like a tiny magnet, and an uneven field pushes on tiny magnets differently depending on which way they point. Classical physics predicted that the atoms would point in all possible directions, so the beam should spread out into a continuous smear. Instead, the beam split cleanly into two separate spots. The atom’s magnetism seemed to come in only two possible orientations, up or down, nothing in between. It was one of the first direct signs that the atomic world follows strange quantized rules where certain properties can only take on a few fixed values. The Stern Gearlock result may have been revealed by cigar smoke. The silver deposited on Stern and Gerlock’s detector plate was incredibly faint, almost invisible.
According to a well-known account of the experiment, the pattern only became visible thanks to cigar smoke. Stern smoked inexpensive cigars, and the sulfur in the smoke reacted with the thin silver deposit, turning it into darker silver sulfide. Suddenly, the two separate lines appeared on the plate. Whether every detail of the story is exact or not, it’s become part of the lore of physics. One of the most important experiments of the 20th century. A glimpse into the hidden structure of atoms coaxed into view by a puff of smoke drifting across a laboratory. In 1925, two young
Chapter 14: Electron spin
, 1 secondphysicists proposed that electrons have spin. Samuel Gaud and George Olinbeck were young Dutch physicists studying puzzling patterns in the light given off by atoms. The patterns didn’t make sense with orbital motion alone. They proposed something bold. The electron itself might have its own built-in angular momentum, a kind of internal rotation, and with it its own built-in magnetism. This property came to be called spin. It would explain the patterns in atomic light, and it would also explain the silver atom splitting into two beams. The electron, they suggested, was not just a tiny charged point moving around. It was itself a tiny magnet carrying its magnetism wherever it went. The name spin is misleading. It’s tempting to picture an electron as a tiny ball rotating on its axis like a spinning top. But that picture doesn’t work. If the electron were a little spinning ball of the size once estimated, its surface would have to move faster than light to produce the angular momentum it actually has, which is impossible.
And in modern experiments, the electron behaves as a point-like particle with no measurable size at all. There’s nothing there to rotate. Spin is a genuine property of the electron as real as its charge or its mass. It carries angular momentum and it carries magnetism. But it isn’t literally spinning. It’s a quantum property with no perfect everyday equivalent. A reminder that the smallest pieces of nature don’t always match the pictures we bring from the humansized world. In 1928, spin appeared naturally from Durac’s equation. Paul Durac set out to combine quantum mechanics with Einstein’s special relativity. building an equation that could describe a fast-moving electron correctly. When he worked out his equation, something remarkable fell out of the mathematics. Spin was simply there. So was the electron’s magnetic moment with very nearly the right size. Nobody had to put it in by hand. Spin wasn’t an extra decoration added to the electron. It emerged from the deep marriage of quantum theory and relativity.
The same equation also predicted the existence of antimatter, the posetron. Few equations in history have revealed so much about the world from so little. And at its heart was the quiet magnetism of the electron. The electron’s magnetism has been measured with astonishing precision. The electron’s spin magnetic moment is almost exactly one bore magneton. Almost, but not quite. Precision measurements show it’s slightly larger by about a tenth of a percent. That tiny difference turned out to be a doorway into deeper physics. According to quantum electronamics, the electron is constantly surrounded by a shimmer of fleeting quantum effects and these slightly enhance its magnetism. Calculations of this extra magnetism match experiments with extraordinary accuracy, making it one of the most precisely tested predictions in all of science. Even the electron’s tiny magnet, it turns out, carries a faint signature of the restless quantum vacuum around it. In 1915, Albert Einstein and Vander Deas made an iron cylinder twist.
They hung a small iron cylinder on a thin thread and suddenly magnetized it. The cylinder rotated slightly. Why? Because magnetism carries angular momentum. When the tiny magnets inside the iron all lined up, their angular momentum lined up too. And to keep the total balanced, the cylinder as a whole had to turn the other way. Einstein and Deas reported a value that matched what orbital motion of electrons would predict. But later measurements by Samuel Barnett and others showed a different value, one that pointed clearly to electron spin. The magnetism of iron comes mainly from spin, not from orbits. A twisting cylinder on a thread had quietly revealed the electron’s hidden nature. An electron’s magnetism needs nothing to keep it going. Here is a central key to tonight’s mystery. An electron spin magnetic moment is permanent. It doesn’t require the electron to move. It doesn’t need to be fed with energy. It doesn’t wear out. A free electron floating in empty space far from any atom carries its magnetism just the same.
It’s simply part of what an electron is. like its charge. Every electron in the universe has carried this tiny magnetism since it came into being. So when we ask what powers a permanent magnet, part of the answer is that nothing needs to. Its magnetism is built from countless electrons, each one carrying a small magnet that was never powered in the first place. But that raises another question. What about the electrons that are moving inside atoms?
Chapter 15: Atomic stability
Shouldn’t they slowly run down? Classical physics said electrons in atoms should lose energy. In the early 20th century, physicists faced a serious problem. According to the classical theory of electricity, an electric charge that changes direction radiates energy as light. An electron circling a nucleus is constantly changing direction. So, it should be constantly radiating. And as it radiates, it should lose energy and spiral inward toward the nucleus. If that were true, every atom would be slowly running down like a spinning top, losing speed. Atoms would decay. Matter would collapse. And of course, every magnet made of atoms would fade, too. This wasn’t a small puzzle. It struck at the very existence of the material world. If classical physics were right, nothing around us could last. Classical calculations predicted that atoms would collapse almost instantly. When physicists worked through the numbers, the result was alarming.
An electron in a hydrogen atom radiating energy, as classical physics demanded, would spiral into the nucleus in roughly a 100 billionth of a second. That’s far quicker than the blink of an eye. In that sliver of time, every atom in the universe would have collapsed. There would be no stable matter. No stars, no planets, no people, no magnets. Clearly, that’s not the world we live in. Atoms are stable. They last billions of years. Something in classical physics had to be wrong, and fixing it would require one of the greatest revolutions in the history of science. In 1911, Ernest Rutherford found the tiny heart of the atom. Rutherford’s team fired small particles at a very thin sheet of gold foil. Most of them passed straight through, as if the foil were almost empty, but a few bounced back sharply, as if they’d hit something small and very dense. Rutherford concluded that an atom’s positive charge and almost all of its mass are concentrated in a tiny nucleus at its center with electrons somewhere around it in mostly empty space.
It was a beautiful discovery. But it also made the collapse problem impossible to ignore. Electrons were clearly outside the nucleus held by electric attraction. By classical rules, they should be spiraling inward. And yet the gold foil and every atom in it stayed perfectly stable. In 1913, Neil’s Boore proposed that electrons can only sit at certain energies. Boore made a daring suggestion. Maybe electrons in atoms can’t have just any energy. Maybe they’re only allowed to occupy certain fixed energy levels like the rungs of a ladder. And while an electron stays on one rung, Boore proposed, it doesn’t radiate at all. It only gives off light when it jumps from a higher rung to a lower one, releasing a precise amount of energy. This explained why atoms give off light only at specific colors. At first, Boore’s idea was more of a rule than an explanation. Nobody knew why electrons should behave this way, but it worked and it pointed the way toward a completely new understanding of nature.
In 1924, Louie De Bruy suggested electrons behave like waves. Light was already known to have both wavelike and particle-like properties. De Bruy, a French physicist, wondered whether the same might be true the other way around, whether particles like electrons might also behave as waves. It seemed an outlandish idea. But in 1927, the American physicists Clinton Davidson and Lester Gurmer fired electrons at a crystal of nickel and saw them defract, spreading into a pattern exactly as waves would. Electrons really do behave like waves. This was the missing piece. If an electron in an atom is a wave, then the strange rules Bore had proposed might follow naturally from the way waves fit into confined spaces. In 1926, Irwin Schroinger wrote down the wave equation. The Austrian physicist Irwin Schroinger found an equation that describes how electron waves behave. When he applied it to an atom, the allowed energy levels appeared naturally without needing to be assumed. It’s like a guitar string.
A string fixed at both ends can only vibrate in certain patterns, producing certain notes. An electron wave confined around a nucleus can only settle into certain patterns, too, each with its own energy. In this picture, a bound electron isn’t a tiny planet circling on a track. It’s described by a smooth cloud of probability surrounding the nucleus, telling us where the electron is likely to be found. The atom became less like a miniature solar system and more like a musical instrument holding steady notes. An electron in a stable state doesn’t radiate. Here is where the collapse problem dissolves. When an electron settles into one of these allowed patterns, physicists call it a stationary state. In a stationary state, the electron’s probability cloud doesn’t change with time. It just sits there steady and unchanging like a note held perfectly still. And because nothing is changing, there’s no orbiting point charge whipping around, nothing to send out light. The atom loses no energy simply by existing.
Classical physics imagined a tiny charged ball racing in circles and radiating. Quantum physics replaces it with a calm, unchanging cloud. The electron isn’t running down because it isn’t running at all. Every atom has a lowest floor called the ground state. Even if electrons could lose energy, there’s a limit to how far they could fall. Every atom has a lowest energy level called the ground state.
Chapter 16: Magnetic materials
For hydrogen, the ground state lies about 13.6 electron volts below a free electron. An electron volt is a tiny unit of energy used in atomic physics. Once an electron reaches the ground state, there’s simply no lower level available. It can’t fall any further because there’s nowhere left to fall. It’s like a ball resting on the lowest floor of the building with no basement. It can sit there forever calmly without slipping. Every atom in a magnet has electrons resting in such steady states, quietly holding their place. The size of an atom comes from a balancing act. Why doesn’t the electron simply crowd right into the nucleus? The answer comes from a principle described by Verer Heisenberg, the uncertainty principle. If you squeeze an electron into a smaller space, its energy of motion rises. Being closer to the nucleus lowers its electrical energy, but confining it raises its kinetic energy. The ground state is the perfect compromise between these two effects.
For hydrogen, that balance gives the atom a size of about 500ths of a nanome, a 20 millionth of a millimeter. The electron can’t get closer without paying more in motion than it gains in attraction. So, the atom settles into a natural size held open by the restlessness of the electron itself. This is the deepest reason a magnet doesn’t run down. Now, we can bring the pieces together. The magnetism of a permanent magnet comes from electrons, mostly from their spin, with some contribution from their motion inside atoms. Spin is a permanent property that needs no energy to maintain. And the electrons inside atoms sit in stable quantum states that don’t radiate and cost nothing to keep. There’s no hidden fuel tank because there’s nothing being used up. Not at the large scale where the magnet holds paper still, and not at the smallest scale where electrons settle into their steady patterns. The magnet’s field is built from things that simply persist. But there’s still a puzzle left.
Most materials are full of electrons, yet most materials aren’t magnets. Why not? Most electrons pair up and cancel each other out. In most atoms, electrons come in pairs, and the two electrons in each pair have opposite spins. One points up, one points down. Their tiny magnets point in opposite directions and cancel each other almost perfectly. That’s why wood, glass, water, paper, and most of the world around us aren’t noticeably magnetic. Their electrons are all neatly paired. Each tiny magnet silenced by its partner. Every object you can see is full of magnetic electrons. But in most of them, the magnetism is hidden, canceled out pair by pair. For a material to become magnetic, something has to break that pattern, leaving some electrons unpaired with their spins free to point the same way. The pi exclusion principle explains why electrons pair up. In 1925, the Austrian physicist Wulf Gang Pi discovered a rule that shapes all of chemistry. No two electrons in the same atom can share exactly the same quantum state.
An electron state includes its energy pattern called an orbital and its spin. So two electrons can share an orbital only if their spins are opposite, one up and one down. A third electron can’t join them at all. It has to go somewhere else. This simple rule is why atoms have the structure they do, why the periodic table looks the way it does, and why matter doesn’t collapse into a dense blob. And it’s why in most materials, electrons settle into opposite spin pairs, their magnetism quietly canled. Friedri Hund discovered that electrons prefer to stay unpaired
Chapter 17: Magnetic domains
when they can. The German physicist Friedri Hund noticed a pattern in how electrons fill orbitals. When there are several orbitals with the same energy, electrons don’t pair up right away. Instead, they spread out one per orbital, all with their spins pointing the same way before any of them begin to pair. It’s like passengers boarding a bus. If there are empty rows, people tend to take a row to themselves before anyone sits next to a stranger. Only when every row has someone in it do people start sharing seats. This preference leaves some atoms with several unpaired electrons all spinning in the same direction. Those atoms carry a net magnetism and they’re the starting point for every magnet. Iron, cobalt, and nickel are rich in unpaired electrons. A free iron atom floating on its own ends up with four unpaired electrons in its outer shell of orbitals. Cobalt has three. Nickel has two. These are the classic magnetic metals. But something changes when atoms join together into a solid.
In solid iron metal, the outer electrons are shared across the whole crystal rather than belonging to one atom. As a result, the average magnetic moment works out to about 2.2 bore magnetons per atom, a little less than the free atom would suggest. Still, that’s a substantial amount of magnetism in every single atom. and it’s ready to be aligned. But unpaired electrons on their own turn out not to be enough. Some materials have unpaired electrons and still don’t stick to a fridge. A free manganese atom has five unpaired electrons, even more than iron. An oxygen molecule has two. Yet, manganese metal doesn’t cling to a magnet the way iron does. And air certainly doesn’t stick to your fridge. So having unpaired electrons isn’t the whole story. Each atom might be a tiny magnet, but if the tiny magnets point in random directions or in opposite directions, they cancel out over the whole material. For a material to become a strong magnet, its atomic magnets need to line up with each other, all pointing the same way.
Something has to persuade them to cooperate. And the force that does this turns out to be very surprising. The direct magnetic pull between atoms is far too weak to align them. You might guess that neighboring atomic magnets line up simply because magnets attract each other. North pulls towards south and the whole crowd falls into line. But when physicists calculated how strong that direct magnetic pull is between neighboring atoms in iron, they found it’s tiny. On its own, it would lose out to the random thermal jiggling of atoms at temperatures of around a degree or less above absolute zero. At room temperature, it wouldn’t stand a chance. And yet, iron stays magnetized at room temperature and even when glowing hot up to hundreds of degrees. So, something far stronger than magnetism is holding the atomic magnets in line. The real force behind a magnet’s order is not magnetic at all. Verer Heisenberg explained the real force in 1928. He called it the exchange interaction.
It comes from a deep property of identical particles in quantum mechanics. All electrons are perfectly identical and quantum rules demand that their combined description obeys strict symmetry. One consequence is that electrons with parallel spins tend to keep apart from each other. They avoid occupying the same region of space. And since electrons repel each other electrically, keeping apart lowers their electrical repulsion energy. So in the right circumstances, lining up spins in parallel saves energy. Not because of magnetism, but because of how electrons arrange themselves to avoid each other. It’s a purely quantum effect with no equivalent in everyday experience and it’s far stronger than the direct magnetic pull between atoms. A fridge magnet is held together by electric repulsion in iron, cobalt, and nickel. The exchange interaction makes parallel alignment of neighboring spins the lowest energy arrangement.
Neighboring , 1 secondatomic magnets line up because doing so lets their electrons keep a little more distance from each other, reducing their electrical repulsion. So the force that holds a magnet’s order together is at its root electrostatic repulsion, filtered through the rules of quantum mechanics. It’s a beautiful twist. The magnetism you feel when a magnet clicks onto a door depends on electricity. Every tiny electron magnet is lined up with its neighbor by the electrical push between them. Electricity and magnetism once again turn out to be partners working together inside every piece of iron. In some materials, exchange makes neighbors point in opposite directions. The exchange interaction doesn’t always favor parallel spins. In some materials, it favors opposite neighbors, each spin pointing the reverse of the one beside it. Chromium is one example at room temperature, and manganese becomes this way at very low temperatures. These materials are called antifromagnets.
They’re highly ordered with every spin locked into a precise alternating pattern. But because neighbors cancel each other, the material as a whole produces no net field. You could hold one in your hand and never know it was magnetically ordered at all. The French physicist Louisie Neil described this kind of order and he received the Nobel Prize in 1970. Perfect order, perfectly hidden. A magnet that keeps its magnetism entirely to itself. Some materials line up only while a magnet is near. In materials like aluminium, platinum and oxygen, the atoms have unpaired electrons, but the exchange coupling between neighbors is too weak to hold them in line against the jiggling of heat. These materials are called paramagnetic. Bring a strong magnet close and their atomic magnets line up weakly with the field so the material is drawn gently toward it. Take the magnet away and the spins scramble again almost instantly back into random disorder. Paramagnets have no memory. They respond then forget. Iron is different. It remembers.
But even iron, as we’re about to see, doesn’t always show its magnetism. An ordinary iron nail hides a secret. An iron nail from a hardware store is not a magnet. Iron is the classic magnetic metal. Its exchange interaction strongly favors aligned spins. So why doesn’t every iron nail act like a magnet? Why doesn’t it stick to other nails or pick up paper clips? Because its magnetic order exists only in small patches. And those patches point in different directions. Inside each patch, every atomic magnet is lined up. But one patch might point left, another right, another up. Taken together, their fields cancel and the nail as a whole shows almost no magnetism. The order is there hidden in a mosaic. To turn the nail into a magnet, you don’t need to create order. You only need to persuade those patches to point the same way. In 1907, Pierre Weiss proposed magnetic domains. The
Chapter 18: Making magnets
French physicist Pierre Weiss suggested that iron is divided into regions, each fully magnetized inside but oriented differently from its neighbors. These regions are now called magnetic domains. Weiss proposed them before anyone could see them. Reasoning backward from how iron behaves, it explained a deep puzzle. how a material could be strongly magnetic at the level of its atoms and yet appear unmagnetized overall. Inside every domain, the atomic magnets march in step. But across domains, the directions vary. It’s like a crowd divided into groups. Each group facing its own direction. From far away, the crowd as a whole seems to face nowhere in particular, even though every person in it is perfectly aligned with their neighbors. Domains form because they save energy. Why doesn’t iron simply become one giant domain with every atomic magnet pointing the same way? Because a single huge domain would send a strong field out into the surrounding space, looping from one end of the metal to the other.
That outside field stores a lot of energy by splitting into domains with different directions. The material lets its field loop back inside itself from one domain into the next instead of spilling outward. Less field outside means less stored energy. So the domains are nature’s way of finding a calmer arrangement. The iron gives up its outward magnetism in exchange for a lower energy, more comfortable state, folding its field inward like someone curling up to keep warm. Domains are small, but each holds vast numbers of atoms. In iron, domains are typically micrometers to hundreds of micrometers across. A micrometer is a thousandth of a millimeter, so many domains are far too small to see with the naked eye. Some are about the width of a human hair, others much smaller. But by atomic standards, they’re enormous. Each domain contains vast numbers of atoms, all aligned together. Their tiny magnets marching in perfect step. So a single iron nail holds a hidden landscape of countless domains.
Each a tiny kingdom of order, fitted together like tiles in an invisible mosaic. Look at the nail and you see plain gray metal, but inside there’s an intricate pattern, quiet and , 1 secondunseen. The walls between domains are gentle twists, not sharp edges. Where one domain meets another, the direction of magnetization has to change. But it doesn’t flip abruptly from one atom to the next. Instead, it twists gradually across a region tens of nanome thick. Each atomic magnet turned just slightly from its neighbor like the steps of a spiral staircase. These boundaries are called domain walls. In 1932, the Swiss American physicist Felix BL analyzed their structure and one common type is now called a block wall. The gradual twist is a compromise. Exchange prefers neighbors to point the same way. So a sudden flip would cost a lot of energy. Spreading the change across many atoms keeps each step small and gentle. In 1919, Hinrich Barkhausen heard domains , 1 secondmoving.
The German physicist Hinrich Barkhousen wound a coil of wire around a piece of iron and connected the coil to a loudspeaker. Then he slowly magnetized the iron with a gradually increasing field. If magnetization changed smoothly, the speaker should have stayed quiet. Instead, he heard crackling, a soft, irregular rustle, like rain on a roof or gravel shifting. What he was hearing were domain walls jumping in tiny, sudden steps, sticking and then lurching forward. Each jump changed the magnetism slightly, sending a little pulse of current through the coil. It’s now called the Barkhousen effect. For the first time, someone had listened to the hidden mosaic inside iron rearranging itself grain by grain. In 1931, Francis Bitter made domains visible. Domains had been predicted and heard, but not seen. The American physicist Francis Bitter found a clever way. He polished a piece of iron until it was smooth, then spread a fine magnetic powder over its surface suspended in liquid.
The tiny particles were drawn to the domain walls where the magnetic field is strongest at the surface. Under a microscope, the powder collected into fine lines outlining the boundaries between domains. Suddenly, the hidden mosaic could be seen. A delicate pattern of shapes etched across the metal. These are called bitter patterns. It’s one of those wonderful moments in science when something reasoned about for decades finally appears before human eyes. Today, scientists can film domains moving. Modern researchers watch domains in real time using an effect called the magneto optical cur effect. When polarized light reflects from a magnetized surface, its polarization rotates very slightly depending on the local direction of magnetization. Domains pointing one way rotate the light one direction. Domains pointing the other way rotate it the opposite direction. With the right filters, the domains show up as light and dark regions.
Apply a magnetic field and you can watch the domains grow, shrink, and shift on a screen. walls gliding across the surface like slow shadows. What Barkhousen once heard as a crackle and bitter outlined with powder, scientists can now watch moving frame by frame. Iron prefers to be magnetized in certain directions. Iron atoms in a crystal arrange themselves in a cubic pattern, like a stack of tiny boxes, and the magnetization inside iron isn’t equally happy pointing every which way. It prefers to point along the edges of those cubes. Magnetizing iron along a cube edge is easy. Magnetizing it along , 1 seconda diagonal takes more effort. This preference for certain crystal directions is called magnetocristallin anosotropy. Anosotropy simply means that properties depend on direction. It comes from the way electron orbitals interact with the arrangement of atoms around them. This might sound like a small detail, but as we’ll see, it’s one of the most important secrets behind the strongest permanent magnets ever made.
Magnetizing iron means persuading domains to point the same way. When you bring a strong magnet near a piece of iron, the iron’s domains begin to change. Domains already pointing roughly along the applied field start to grow, their walls sliding outward and swallowing their neighbors. Domains pointing in other directions shrink. In stronger fields, whole domains rotate their magnetization to line up with the field. Eventually, almost every domain points the same way, and the material is said to be saturated, as magnetized as it can possibly be. This is how you can magnetize a needle by stroking it with a magnet. You’re not adding magnetism. You’re simply coaxing the hidden mosaic into alignment so that all its separate voices finally sing the same note. Soft iron forgets its magnetism almost immediately. In very pure soft iron, domain walls slide easily. Bring a magnet near and the walls glide, aligning the domains. Take the magnet away and the walls glide right back, returning the iron to its scrambled, unmagnetized state.
Soft iron is easy to magnetize and just as easy to demagnetize. That makes it perfect for some jobs. In electromagnets and transformers, you want a material whose magnetism follows the current exactly and disappears when the current stops. But it makes soft iron useless as a permanent magnet. A
Chapter 19: Types of magnets
permanent magnet needs the opposite quality. Once its domains are aligned, they need to stay aligned, holding their pattern long after the magnetizing field is gone. Permanent magnets work by getting their domain walls stuck. To make a magnet that remembers, the domain walls need to stop sliding back. One way is to fill the material with obstacles, impurities, grain boundaries between tiny crystals, and microscopic inclusions of other substances. A domain wall moving through the material gets caught on these obstacles and pinned in place, like a sheet snagging on nails. Another approach is to build the material so that reverse domains can’t easily form at all. Either way, once the material is magnetized, its domains stay aligned because the walls that would let them change are stuck or missing. This is the quiet engineering inside every permanent magnet. Its strength isn’t stored fuel. It’s frozen order, held firmly in place. A material’s resistance to being demagnetized is called coercivity.
Physicists measure how firmly a material holds its magnetism using a quantity called coercivity. It’s the strength of the opposing field you’d need to apply to cancel the material’s magnetization. Soft magnetic materials, like those used in transformer cores, have very low coercivity. Their magnetism yields to the slightest push. Hard magnetic materials, the kind used in permanent magnets, have very high coercivity. They resist strongly, holding their alignment even when pushed against. A fridge magnet, a speaker magnet, the magnets in an electric motor, all of them are chosen for their stubbornness, their ability to keep their order intact through years of daily use. A material’s magnetic memory can be drawn as a loop. If you slowly increase a magnetic field on a material, then decrease it, reverse it, and bring it back again, and you plot the material’s magnetization at each step, you get a closed curve called a hysteresus loop. Hysteresus comes from a Greek word meaning lagging behind.
The material’s magnetization lags behind the applied field, remembering where it has been. For soft iron, the loop is thin, almost a single line because the iron forgets immediately. For a permanent magnet, the loop is wide because the material clings to its magnetization even when the field is removed or reversed. The wider the loop, the more firmly the material remembers how it was magnetized. A magnet, in a sense, is a material with a long memory. Alnico magnets get their strength from tiny needles. In the 1930s, scientists developed alniko alloys of aluminium, nickel, and cobalt along with iron. These became some of the first truly strong permanent magnets. Their secret lies in their internal structure. Inside Alnico, the metal separates into tiny needle-shaped magnetic regions surrounded by less magnetic material. A long thin magnetic region strongly prefers to be magnetized along its length. Flipping its direction is difficult because the shape itself resists reversal.
So alniko magnets get their stubbornness from geometry from countless microscopic needles. Each one holding its direction firmly. Alnico magnets were common in older loudspeakers and in the classic red horseshoe magnets once found in classrooms. Ferite magnets are cheap, sturdy, and everywhere. In the 1950s, ferite magnets arrived. They’re ceramics based on iron oxide mixed with other elements, pressed and baked like pottery. They aren’t the strongest magnets, but they’re inexpensive and they don’t rust because the iron is already combined with oxygen. That makes them perfect for everyday use. Fite is in most fridge magnets, including the flexible ones made from ferite powder in rubber. It’s in many loudspeakers and small motors. If you’ve ever held a dark gray, slightly brittle magnet, it was probably fite, a humble material, quietly holding notes and photographs to doors in homes. All over the world, Samarium cobalt magnets keep working in the heat.
In the 1960s, researchers developed magnets made from samarium, a rare earth element combined with cobalt. These magnets have very strong anosotropy. Their crystal structure strongly prefers to be magnetized in one direction which makes them extremely resistant to demagnetization and they keep working at high temperatures where many other magnets begin to weaken. That makes them valuable in aerospace and other demanding settings in places where heat, vibration, and reliability all matter at once. They’re more expensive than ferite, but when a magnet absolutely has to keep its strength in harsh conditions, samarium cobalt is often the quiet choice. The strongest common magnets were discovered twice at almost the same time. Around 1982, two researchers on opposite sides of the world independently discovered a new kind of magnet.
Masato Sagawa working at Sumitomo Special Metals in Japan and John Crowit working at General Motors in the United States each found that combining neodymium, iron, and boron produced extraordinarily strong magnets. These neodymium magnets are now the strongest permanent magnets widely available. A small one, no bigger than a coin, can grip so fiercely that prying it off a steel surface takes real effort. Two of them can snap together hard enough to pinch skin, a remarkable leap in strength, arriving almost simultaneously from two separate laboratories. Neodymium magnets owe their power to one special crystal. Their strength comes from a crystal compound with two atoms of neodymium for every 14 atoms of iron and one atom of boron. The iron provides plenty of magnetism. The neodymium provides powerful anosotropy making the magnetization strongly prefer one particular crystal direction and manufacturers give the material a fine grain structure that makes it hard for reversed regions to form.
Together, these qualities produce magnets that are both strong and stubborn. Small amounts of dprosium or turbium are often added to help the magnets stay stable when they get hot. It’s a carefully balanced recipe, each ingredient playing its part, and the result is a magnet of astonishing grip in a very small space. Neodymium magnets are hidden all around us. These strong little magnets now sit in electric vehicle motors and in wind turbines, turning motion into electricity, or electricity into motion. They’re in headphones, shaping sound. They’re in the tiny vibration motors that make a phone buzz. They’ve long been part of computer hard drives, too. And hard drives tell their own quiet story about magnetism. For decades, data has been stored on spinning discs as tiny regions magnetized in one of two directions representing the ones and zeros of digital information. Those regions keep their orientation without any power at all. Unplug the drive, put it in a drawer, and the patterns stay.
Photographs, letters, and memories held in place by the same frozen order that keeps a magnet on your fridge. Heat is
Chapter 20: Magnet fading
the most dramatic enemy of a magnet. Now we come to the honest part of tonight’s story. A magnet never runs out of energy, but it can lose its magnetism. And the most dramatic way is heat. As a material warms up, its atoms jiggle more and more. At first, the exchange interaction holds the spins in line despite the jiggling. But above a certain temperature called the cury temperature, thermal motion overwhelms the exchange interaction. The spins can no longer stay aligned and the magnetism collapses. It’s a bit like a crystal melting. Order gives way to disorder all at once. The temperature is named after the French physicist Pierre Cury who studied how magnetism changes with heat. Every magnetic material has its own cury point, its own threshold where order dissolves. Different materials lose their magnetism at very different temperatures. Iron’s cury temperature is about 770° C. Heat iron beyond that until it glows and it stops being magnetic. Cobalt holds on longer until roughly,00 to,30°.
Nickel gives up much earlier at about 355° C. Neodymium magnets lose their magnetism at roughly 310 to 400° C depending on their exact recipe. And then there’s gatalinium, a rare earth metal that loses its ferromagnetism at only about 20°. Celsius, close to room temperature. On a cool day, it can be magnetic. On a warm day, it isn’t a metal whose magnetism comes and goes with the weather. Neodymium magnets can weaken well below their cury point. The cury temperature is where magnetism collapses completely. But practical magnets can start to lose strength permanently at much lower temperatures. Standard grades of neodymium magnet often begin to lose some magnetism for good at around 80° C. That’s hotter than a summer day, but not much hotter than a cup of hot tea. At those temperatures, the extra thermal jiggling helps some regions flip their magnetization. And once flipped, they don’t flip back on cooling. That’s why manufacturers make heat resistant grades, often with added dprosium or turbium for motors and other places that run hot.
The strongest magnets aren’t always the toughest ones. Strength and endurance are separate qualities and engineers have to balance them carefully. A magnet heated past its cury point won’t remember its old magnetism. Suppose you heat a magnet beyond its cury temperature. So the magnetism collapses and then let it cool. As it cools below the cury point, the exchange interaction takes over again and the spins realign within domains. But they don’t realign the way they were before. New domains form, pointing in random directions, their fields cancelling each other. The material ends up as ordinary, unmagnetized metal, just like a fresh iron nail. Its old magnetism hasn’t hidden somewhere. It’s simply gone. To make it a magnet again, you’d need to remagnetize it with a strong external field. Heat doesn’t drain a magnet’s energy. It erases its memory, wiping the slate clean. A strong opposing field can reverse a magnet. Heat isn’t the only threat.
A sufficiently strong magnetic field pointing against a magnet’s own magnetization can push its domain walls past the obstacles that pin them. Regions flip, the walls move, and the magnet can be partly or fully reversed. This is exactly what coercivity measures, how strong that opposing field needs to be. Hard magnets have high coercivity. So, it takes a powerful field to undo them, but it can be done. It’s also why strong magnets can scramble the magnetic stripes on older bank cards and damage older magnetic storage media. Those stripes and tapes hold their information in weakly pinned magnetic regions, and a strong magnet nearby can rearrange them in an instant. A magnet’s own field quietly works against it. Every magnet’s field loops from its north pole around to its south pole. But inside the magnet, part of that returning field points against the magnet’s own magnetization, gently pushing it toward disorder. This is the self-demagnetizing effect we met earlier.
Short, wide shapes suffer from it more because their poles are close together. That’s why old horseshoe magnets were often stored with an iron bar across their poles called a keeper. The keeper gave the field an easy path to loop through so it didn’t have to push back through the magnet itself. A small bar of iron resting across the two ends, protecting the magnet from its own field, like a hand placed gently over a candle flame to shield it from a draft. Shock and corrosion can weaken a magnet, too. Hammering a magnet or dropping it again and again, especially an older steel magnet, can shake domain walls loose from their pinning points. Each jolt gives the walls a chance to slide, and over time, the magnets alignment can loosen. Modern hard magnets are far more resistant to this, but older steel ones could lose noticeable strength from rough treatment. Neodymium magnets face a different threat, which is corrosion. The iron and neodymium in them react with moisture and air. And the magnet can crumble chemically over time.
That’s why neodymium magnets are almost always coated, usually with a shiny layer of nickel or with zinc or epoxy. The coating keeps the air out so the magnets crystal order can stay intact. Even left alone, magnets fade very slightly over time. At room temperature, the atoms in a magnet are always jiggling a little. Most of the time, that jiggling isn’t nearly enough to flip any regions. But every so often, a rare thermal fluctuation lets a tiny region flip its direction. Over long periods, these rare flips add up to a very slow loss of strength. Scientists call this magnetic viscosity. For good modern magnets, the loss is estimated at around a percent or less over many years. And most of it happens in the first period after the magnet is magnetized. After that early settling, the remaining magnetism is extremely stable. It’s a fading so slow that on human time scales, the word permanent is very nearly true. Stum rocks have held their magnetism for more than 3 billion years. Nature runs the longest magnet experiment of all.
When volcanic lava cools, or when fine sediment settles slowly in water, tiny magnetic mineral grains inside line up with Earth’s magnetic field at that moment. As the rock hardens, that alignment gets locked in, a frozen record of the field’s direction. Geologists can measure this ancient magnetism today. And some rocks more than 3 billion years old still carry a measurable trace of the magnetism they acquired when they formed. Think about that. Long before there were plants on land, before there were animals, these grains lined up and they’ve kept that alignment ever since through billions of years of quiet waiting. If you’ve ever wondered how we know magnetism can last, the rocks themselves have been answering. A magnet never runs out like a battery. Every way a magnet can weaken has something in common. Heat scramles its spins. Opposing fields push its walls. Its own field nudges against it. Shock shakes its domains loose. Corrosion breaks down its crystal. and rare thermal flips nibble away at it very slowly.
In every case, the field fades only when something disturbs the ordered alignment of its electron spins. Nothing is being spent. Nothing is being used up. A battery goes flat because it consumes a chemical store of energy. A magnet doesn’t have a store to consume. It only has order. And order lasts until something breaks it. Leave a good magnet alone, cool and undisturbed, and it will
Chapter 21: Diamagnetism
simply keep holding on, just as the rocks have done for billions of years. Every material responds to magnetism, even water. It’s easy to think of materials as magnetic or not magnetic. Iron on one side, everything else on the other. But in fact, every material responds to magnetic fields in some way. When a magnetic field is applied to any substance, the motion of electrons inside its atoms adjusts slightly and this adjustment creates a small magnetic response that opposes the applied field. This is called diamagnetism and it happens in every atom. Water, wood, plastic, copper, even your own body, all of them are very faintly repelled by a magnet. Usually, the effect is so small that you’d never notice it, but it’s always there, quietly pushing back. Diamagnetism is incredibly weak. The diamagnetic response of most materials is typically millions of times weaker than the response of iron. That’s why water, wood, copper, and the human body seem completely unaffected by ordinary magnets.
Hold a fridge magnet next to your hand and you feel nothing. But the push is there, far too faint for your senses to register. To make diamagnetism do something visible, you need an extremely powerful magnetic field. And when scientists finally built one strong enough, they used it to do something that sounds like it belongs in a fairy tale. They made a living frog float in midair. In 1997, a live frog levitated in a magnetic field. At Radbow University in Naimmean in the Netherlands, Andre Gime and his colleagues placed a small live frog inside the bore of a powerful electromagnet producing roughly 10 to 16 Tesla. The frog rose and floated in midair, hovering calmly in the field. What was holding it up? Not any iron inside the frog. It was the frog’s water. A frog is mostly water, and water is diamagnetic. In a strong enough field, the faint push from every water molecule in the frog’s body added up to enough force to balance gravity. The frog seemed unharmed by the experience.
Somewhere in the Netherlands, a frog once drifted weightless, held up by the gentle repulsion of its own water. The floating frog led to one of science’s most unusual double honors. In 2000, Andre Gime and the physicist Michael Barry received the Ignobbel Prize for the levitating frog. The Ignobbel Prizes celebrate research that first makes people laugh and then makes them think. 10 years later in 2010, Guime won the real Nobel Prize in physics for his work on graphine, a sheet of carbon just one atom thick. That made him the first person to hold both prizes. It’s a lovely reminder that playful curiosity and serious discovery aren’t opposites. The same mind that floated a frog went on to help reveal one of the most remarkable materials ever studied. Strawberries, tomatoes, and a grasshopper have floated, too. The same laboratory in Nymegan levitated many other things in its powerful magnets. Water droplets drifted in the field like tiny planets. Strawberries floated. Cherry tomatoes floated. A small grasshopper floated too.
All of them are mostly water and all of them were held up by diamagnetism. Some materials are even more strongly diamagnetic than water. Pyrolytic graphite, a specially layered form of carbon, is among the strongest of all. A thin piece of it can hover above ordinary neodymium magnets right on a desk with no special laboratory needed. It just floats there silently, a small gray sheet resting on nothing but the push of the field. Paramagnetic materials line up weakly with a field. Some materials contain unpaired electron spins that aren’t strongly coupled to each other. When a magnetic field is applied, those spins line up weakly with it, and the material is gently drawn toward the magnet. take the field away and the spins become disordered again almost immediately. These are paramagnetic materials. Their response is usually much stronger than diamagnetism, but still far weaker than iron. Aluminium is paramagnetic. So is oxygen.
Paramagnets are like an audience that turns toward a speaker while the speaker is talking, then drifts back into casual chatter the moment the speaker falls silent. They respond, but they don’t remember. Liquid oxygen clings between the poles of a magnet. Oxygen gas is invisible and seems to have nothing to do with magnetism. But cool it until it becomes a liquid, a pale blue liquid colder than – 180° C and pour it between the poles of a strong magnet. Instead of splashing straight through, it clings there, forming a pale blue bridge between the two poles, suspended by the field. The reason is that each oxygen molecule carries two unpaired electrons, which makes oxygen paramagnetic. In the liquid, the molecules are packed closely enough that their combined attraction becomes visible. The air you’re breathing right now is very slightly magnetic. You’d never notice it in a breath, but in a cold blue liquid, it reveals itself. Lining up spins can move heat. When you magnetize certain materials, aligning their spins, they warm up slightly.
When you demagnetize them, letting the spins scatter, they cool down. This is called the magnetocaloric effect. In 1933, the American chemist William Jock used it to reach extraordinarily low temperatures. He magnetized a paramagnetic salt, let the heat produced flow away, then insulated the salt, and slowly removed the field. As the spins scattered, they drew heat from the salt itself, cooling it dramatically. This technique helped scientists reach temperatures just a fraction of a degree above absolute zero. A gentle trick of order and disorder, pulling heat out of matter, one spin at a time. Magnetic refrigeration may one day cool our
Chapter 22: Superconductivity
homes. The magnetocaloric effect isn’t only useful in the deep cold of laboratories. Researchers are developing magnetic refrigeration that works near everyday temperatures. The idea uses materials such as alloys of gatalinium whose magnetic order changes close to room temperature. Magnetize the material and it warms so the heat can be carried away. Demagnetize it and it cools, drawing heat from whatever you want to chill. Repeat the cycle and you have a refrigerator with no conventional refrigerant gas. It’s still being developed as a possible alternative to conventional cooling, but it’s a lovely idea, cooling food and homes simply by aligning and releasing tiny spins over and over in a quiet rhythm. In 1911, electrical resistance vanished completely. In Leiden in the Netherlands, the physicist Hikah Camarling Onis cooled mercury using liquid helium which he had been the first to produce. At about 4.2 Kelvin, just a few degrees above absolute zero, something astonishing happened. The Mercury’s electrical resistance disappeared.
Not reduced, not nearly gone, but completely vanished. Electric current could flow through it without any loss at all. This was the discovery of superc conductivity. It was so unexpected that it took decades for physicists to understand why it happens and it opened the door to a world where currents and magnetic fields could last almost indefinitely with no fuel needed to sustain them. A current in a superconducting ring can flow for an astonishingly long time. Start an electric current flowing around a ring of superconducting material. Then disconnect any battery or power supply. The current keeps going round and round with nothing pushing it. With no resistance, there’s nothing to slow it down. In a 1963 experiment, researchers estimated that such a current would take at least on the order of a 100,000 years to decay noticeably. A current circling silently in a loop longer than all of recorded human history with no fuel at all. It’s the same lesson we learned with the fridge magnet, but even more striking.
A magnetic field costs nothing to keep once there’s no friction to fight. Superconductors push magnetic fields away. In 1933, the German physicists Walter Meisner and Robert Oxenfeld discovered something remarkable about superconductors. When a material becomes superconducting, it actively pushes magnetic fields out of its interior. Field lines that once passed through the material are expelled, bending around it instead. This is now called the Mner effect. It’s why a small magnet can float above a cooled superconductor, hovering in place as the superconductor pushes against its field. You’ve probably seen pictures of it, a little magnet floating above a disc wrapped in cold vapor. It looks like magic, but it’s simply the superconductor refusing to let the field inside. Some superconductors lock magnets in place. In many modern superconductors, the expulsion of magnetic fields isn’t complete. Instead, thin threads of magnetic flux get trapped inside the material, pinned in place by tiny imperfections.
Those pinned threads hold the magnet’s position firmly. The result is surprising to watch. A magnet can be locked in place above a superconductor or below it or beside it at any angle as if held by invisible hands. Tilt the superconductor and the magnet tilts with it. Turn it upside down and the magnet hangs underneath without falling. This is often demonstrated as quantum levitation. It’s a vivid reminder that magnetic fields in the right conditions can be held, shaped, and frozen in place like threads woven into fabric. MRI scanners use superconducting magnets that stay on for years. A hospital MRI scanner creates its strong magnetic field using coils of superconducting wire. Once the current is established in those coils, the scanner can run in what’s called persistent mode. The main magnetic field can stay on for years without being continuously powered because the current circles through the superconducting coils with no loss. What the scanner does need is cooling.
Liquid helium keeps the coils cold enough to remain superconducting. So the field itself is almost free to maintain just like our fridge magnet. The ongoing cost is keeping the wire cold. The magnetism simply stays a steady invisible presence filling the room year after year. An MRI
Chapter 23: Magnetism in medicine
scanner listens to the hydrogen in your body. Your body is full of water and every water molecule contains hydrogen atoms. The nucleus of each hydrogen atom is a single proton. And each proton carries a tiny magnetic moment. When you lie inside an MRI scanner, its strong field lines up a small fraction of these proton magnets. Then the scanner nudges them with pulses of radio waves. As the protons realign afterward, they give off faint radio signals of their own. By listening carefully to those signals, the scanner builds detailed images of soft tissues inside the body. The physicists Paul Lau and Peter Mansfield received the Nobel Prize in 2003 for developing the imaging method, the magnetism of protons, quietly mapping the inside of a living person. Strong scanners can make people feel dizzy. Some people moving into the bore of a strong MRI scanner feel a sense of dizziness or vertigo. For a long time, the cause wasn’t clear. In 2011, a study traced it to the inner ear.
Deep inside your ear is a balance organ filled with fluid that contains charged particles. In the scanner’s strong magnetic field, those moving charges feel a force. And that force pushes on the fluid, nudging the balance organ much as a turning motion would. Your brain interprets that push as movement, even though you’re lying still. It’s a gentle illustration of how magnetism acts on moving charges right inside your own head, quietly tipping your sense of balance. In 2024, the world’s most powerful MRI scanner showed the living human brain. In France, a scanner called Isert was built with an 11.7 Tesla magnet, several times stronger than ordinary hospital scanners. The magnet weighs about 132 tons and is cooled to under 2° above absolute zero. In April 2024, ESULt released its first images of the living human brain, revealing fine details that ordinary scanners can’t resolve.
A giant superconducting magnet as heavy as a blue whale, colder than deep space, holding its field steady, so that researchers can look gently inside a human mind. Magnetism. Once a mystery in a load stone, now helping us see the brain itself. The strongest steady magnetic fields on Earth reach about 45 Tesla. In specialized laboratories, scientists push magnetic fields to extremes. The strongest steady fields made on Earth are around 45 Tesla produced in hybrid and superconducting laboratory magnets in China and the United States. That’s roughly a million times stronger than Earth’s own field. Pulsed magnets can go even further, reaching about 100 Tesla, but only for fractions of a second before the forces involved become too great. Such fields let scientists study how materials behave under extreme conditions, revealing strange new properties of matter. They’re among the most intense magnetic environments humans have ever created. Magnetars dwarf every magnet on Earth.
Even the strongest laboratory magnets are tiny compared to what nature can produce. A magnetar is a rare type of collapsed star, a neutron star with an extraordinarily intense magnetic field. Its field is estimated at roughly a billion to 100 billion Tesla. That’s billions of times stronger than the strongest steady magnet ever made on Earth. In fields like that, atoms themselves would be distorted, stretched out of their usual shapes. No laboratory could ever reach such strengths. Magnetars are far away, scattered across the galaxy, small and dense, and wrapped in invisible force. They’re the far end of magnetism’s ladder, as far from the whisper of Earth’s field as anything can be. Earth’s magnetic field is not made
Chapter 24: Planetary magnetism
by a giant buried magnet. Remember William Gilbert who concluded that Earth itself is a magnet. He was right that earth is magnetic but the reason isn’t a gigantic load stone at the center of the planet. The core is far too hot for that. Earth’s core is thousands of degrees far hotter than the cury temperature of iron. The point where iron loses its permanent magnetism. No permanent magnet could survive down there. So where does Earth’s field come from? It turns out the planet’s magnetism is not frozen at all. It’s alive in a sense, constantly being made and remade by motion deep beneath our feet. Earth’s field is made by flowing liquid metal. Deep inside Earth, roughly 2,900 to 5,100 km below the surface, lies the outer core. It’s a vast layer of liquid iron and nickel, hotter than the surface of the sun in places, flowing slowly but constantly. Because this liquid metal conducts electricity, its motion generates electric currents, and those currents generate magnetic fields. This process is called the geodynamo.
It’s not a magnet in the usual sense. It’s more like a generator turning motion into magnetism endlessly. The field that turns every compass needle on the surface is being created right now by a slow ocean of molten metal churning far below. Heat and earth’s spin drive the geodynamo. Why does the outer core keep moving? Heat escaping from the deep interior drives convection with hotter metal rising and cooler metal sinking. A little like water in a pot on a stove. At the same time, the solid inner core slowly grows as the liquid around it freezes onto its surface, releasing heat and lighter elements that stir the flow even more. Earth’s rotation then twists these flows into columns and spirals. Together, convection and rotation organize the moving metal into patterns that sustain and amplify the magnetic field. The planet spin and it’s slowly escaping heat. Working together keep the dynamo running. A dynamo like Earth’s keeps itself going once it starts. The geodynamo is self- sustaining.
Only a tiny initial magnetic field is needed to get it started. Once the liquid metal begins flowing through that field, it generates currents which strengthen the field which in turn generates more current in the moving metal. The flowing iron keeps regenerating the field as long as the motion continues. Exactly how Earth’s field first began is still not fully known. Perhaps a faint stray field was enough, amplified over time. But once it started, it has kept itself going for billions of years, powered not by a store of magnetism, but by the ongoing motion of the core. Here, unlike the fridge magnet, energy really is being spent, drawn from the planet’s internal heat. The age of Earth’s solid inner core is still uncertain. At the very center of Earth lies a solid ball of iron and nickel, the inner core, slowly growing as the liquid outer core cools and freezes onto it. Scientists have tried to work out when it first began to freeze, but estimates range widely from around half a billion years to over a billion years.
That means the geodynamo may have been running for billions of years before the inner core even existed. For much of Earth’s history, the field may have been powered by different processes than today. It’s one of the open questions about our planet’s deep past. How the heart of Earth has changed while its field kept protecting the surface. Scientists have built dynamos in the laboratory. To test how planetary dynamos work, scientists built experiments using liquid sodium, a metal that conducts electricity very well and melts at a fairly low temperature. Around 1999 and 2000, experiments in Ria in Latvia and in Carlrua in Germany pumped liquid sodium through carefully designed channels and generated self- sustaining magnetic fields. The flowing metal created and maintained its own field just as theory predicted. In 2006, a French experiment near Katarash even produced spontaneous reversals of its magnetic field, flipping north and south on its own.
Small humming machines recreating in a laboratory the same process that shapes the magnetism of an entire planet. Earth’s field is stronger in some places than others. At the surface, Earth’s magnetic field isn’t the same everywhere. It’s strongest near the magnetic poles where field lines dive steeply into the ground. It’s weakest in a broad region over South America and the South Atlantic Ocean. Across the planet, the field ranges from roughly 25 to 65 millionths of a Tesla. These variations reflect the complex patterns of flow in the outer core, not a simple bar magnet buried at the center. The field is lumpy and uneven, shaped by the turbulent motion of molten metal thousands of kilome below. And as we’ll see shortly, that weak region over the South Atlantic is changing in ways scientists are watching closely. Mars once had a magnetic field and lost it.
Chapter 25: Field changes
Mars, too, once had a global magnetic field. We know because magnetized rocks in its ancient crust still preserve the traces of that field, frozen in place billions of years ago. But the Martian dynamo shut down long ago. Mars is smaller than Earth, so its interior cooled faster and at some point the motion in its core faded and its field faded with it. The loss of that magnetic shield is thought to have helped the solar wind, the stream of charged particles flowing from the sun, strip away much of the Martian atmosphere, a world that may once have been wetter and warmer, slowly thinning out after its magnetism fell silent. Auroras are Earth’s magnetic field made visible. The sun constantly sends out a stream of charged particles called the solar wind. Earth’s magnetic field steers most of those particles around the planet like water flowing around a stone, but some are guided along magnetic field lines down toward the polar regions.
There they collide with atoms and molecules in the upper atmosphere, giving them energy, which those atoms then release as light. That light is the aurora, the northern and southern lights. Green auroras come from oxygen at lower altitudes and red auroras come from oxygen higher up. On a dark winter night near the poles, shimmering curtains of color ripple across the sky, quietly tracing the shape of the invisible field that wraps the earth. The north magnetic pole is always on the move. In 1831, the British explorer James Clark Ross located the North Magnetic Pole, the place where compass needles point straight down in what is now northern Canada. It hasn’t stayed there. Since then, it has moved more than a thousand km, wandering across the Arctic towards Siberia. The pole isn’t a fixed point on the map. It drifts following changes in the flow of liquid metal deep in the core. The spot that Ross reached nearly two centuries ago is now far from where any compass would point.
Earth’s magnetic north is a traveler slowly walking across the top of the world. The poles drift sped up, then slowed down. For much of history, the north magnetic pole moved slowly, typically 10 km a year or less. Then in the 1990s, it began to accelerate and around the early 2000s, it was racing at roughly 50 to 60 km per year. More recently, it has slowed again. According to Noah, the American agency that helps track Earth’s field. In the past year, it moved about 36 km. The South magnetic pole, meanwhile, moved about 9 km. Why the pole sped up and then slowed is tied to shifting patterns of flow in the core and scientists continue to study it. The planet’s magnetism has its own rhythms, sometimes hurrying, sometimes resting. Phones and ships rely on a model of Earth’s moving field. Because the magnetic field keeps changing, navigation systems need an upto-date description of it. That description is the world magnetic model used by phones, aircraft, ships, and many other systems that rely on magnetic directions.
It’s updated every 5 years so that compasses and navigation software stay accurate as the poles drift. The current version called the World Magnetic Model 2025 was released in late 2024 together with a new highresolution version that captures finer detail. Every time your phone shows which way you’re facing, it’s quietly drawing on careful measurements of a field generated by molten metal thousands of kilome below. Earth’s magnetic field has flipped many times. Volcanic rocks and seafloor basults record the direction of Earth’s field at the time they formed, and they reveal something astonishing. Earth’s field has repeatedly flipped with north and south swapping places. In some rocks, the magnetism points one way. In older rocks, it points the opposite way. On the ocean floor, where new crust forms at mid ocean ridges and spreads outward, these flips appear as stripes of alternating magnetization running parallel to the ridges, like a tape recording of the field’s history.
In the 1960s, those stripes became key evidence for plate tectonics, showing that the seafloor is slowly spreading apart. Magnetism helped reveal that the continents themselves are moving. Earth’s field has reversed at least 183 times in 83 million years. That works out to about one reversal every 450,000 years on average. But the timing is highly irregular. Sometimes reversals come close together. Sometimes the field holds steady for a very long time. During a period called the Cretaceous normal supercron in the age of the dinosaurs, the field didn’t reverse at all for about 37 million years. Nobody can yet predict when the next reversal will happen. The field doesn’t follow a clock. It follows the complex turbulent motion of the core, which can stay stable for ages or shift in ways that , 1 secondare still not fully understood. The last full reversal happened about 780,000 years ago. It’s called the Brunes Matuyama reversal, named after the scientists who studied the ancient magnetism that recorded it.
Since then, magnetic north has stayed roughly in the north. How long does a reversal take? Estimates range from about a thousand years to tens of thousands of years. During that time, the field weakens and becomes more complicated with multiple poles appearing in different places before eventually settling into the opposite orientation. A reversal isn’t a sudden flip like a switch. It’s a slow untidy transition unfolding over many human lifetimes. Sometimes the field weakens without fully reversing. Besides full reversals, Earth’s field sometimes goes through shorter episodes called excursions. During the Lashamp event about 41,000 years ago, the field seems to have weakened to a small fraction of its present strength for a few centuries. The poles may have wandered far from their usual positions. Then the field recovered, returning to its original orientation instead of flipping. Excursions like this show that the geodynamo can stumble and recover. The field isn’t a steady, unchanging shield.
It strengthens and weakens, wanders and returns, following the restless motion of the liquid metal far below. Earth’s field has weakened by about 9% in two centuries. Scientists have been measuring Earth’s magnetic field carefully since the early 1800s and more recently with satellites. Over the last two centuries, the global field has weakened by about 9%. It’s natural to wonder whether this means a reversal is approaching, but researchers discuss it as part of the field’s natural variability. The field has risen and fallen many times in the past without reversing. There’s no reliable way yet to predict whether a reversal is coming or when. What we can say is that the field is changing as it always has and scientists are watching it more closely than ever before. A weak spot in the field over the South Atlantic is growing. The South Atlantic anomaly is a region of unusually weak magnetic field stretching across the ocean between South America and Africa. It was first identified in the 19th century.
Since 2014, the European Space Ay’s Swarm satellites have been measuring it in detail. Between 2014 and 2025, the anomaly grew by an area close to half the size of continental Europe, and it’s not changing evenly. A second center of weakness has developed southwest of Africa, where the field has weakened especially quickly in recent years. It’s another sign that the patterns of flow deep in the core are shifting, slowly, redrawing the shape of the field above. The South Atlantic Anomaly is no danger on the ground. Down here on the surface, the weak field over the South Atlantic poses no danger. The atmosphere still protects everything below, but high above, it matters. Satellites passing through the anomaly receive more radiation because the weaker field lets charged particles reach closer to Earth there. That extra radiation can cause electronic glitches in spacecraft. Some space telescopes pause their most sensitive observations as they pass through the region, waiting until they’re clear before resuming.
For those of us on the ground, the anomaly is invisible, a subtle dip in a field we never feel. For the machines circling above, it’s a patch of rougher weather they pass through again and again.
Chapter 26: Magnetic senses
Robins sensed the tilt of Earth’s magnetic field. In the 1960s and 1970s, the German scientists Wulfgang and Rosvita Vilsko studied European robins kept in cages during their migration season. At that time of year, migratory birds become restless and hop in the direction they’d normally fly. The Viltos found that the robins oriented their restlessness according to the magnetic field around them. change the field and the birds changed direction. Even more surprising, the robins didn’t sense which end of the field was north. Instead, they sensed the tilt of the field lines, the angle at which they dip into the ground. A small bird with no instruments at all reading the hidden geometry of the planet’s magnetism. The tilt of the field can tell an animal where it is. Earth’s magnetic field lines run nearly flat at the equator and dive steeply into the ground near the poles. Remember William Gilbert’s terrella, where compass needles lay flat in the middle and dipped at the ends. That tilt is called the inclination angle.
By sensing it, an animal can tell roughly which hemisphere it’s in and how far it is from the equator. Steep field lines mean high latitudes near the poles. Shallow field lines mean low latitudes nearer the equator. A migrating bird doesn’t need to know which way is north. It only needs to know whether it’s heading toward the poles or toward the equator. And the tilting field lines quietly tell it. Birds may sense magnetism through a chemical reaction in their eyes. How does a bird actually feel the magnetic field? One leading idea is that it happens in the eye through a chemical reaction triggered by light. In this picture, a protein called cryptochrome found in the retina absorbs light and forms pairs of molecules whose electrons have linked spins. The way those linked spins evolve is subtly affected by Earth’s magnetic field, which in turn changes the outcome of the chemical reaction. If this is right, birds might literally see the magnetic field, perhaps as a faint pattern laid over their vision.
It’s a remarkable idea that the quantum behavior of electron spins. The same spins that make a fridge magnet stick might guide birds across continents. A Robin’s cryptochrome protein responds to magnetism in the laboratory. In 2021, researchers studied a particular form of the protein called cryptochrome 4 taken from European robins. They showed that it is magnetically sensitive in the laboratory, more so than the same protein from chickens and pigeons, birds that don’t migrate the way robins do. That’s an intriguing clue, suggesting that migratory birds might have a more finely tuned version of the molecule. But it hasn’t yet been proven that this protein is the compass in living birds. Showing that a molecule responds to magnetism in a test tube is one thing. Showing that a bird uses it to find its way is another. The research continues step by careful step. Radio noise from electronics can confuse migrating robins. In 2014, experiments in Oldenberg in Germany found something unexpected.
European robins kept in wooden huts on the university campus had trouble orienting with their magnetic compass. The researchers discovered that weak broadband radio noise, the kind produced by ordinary electronics in a city, was disrupting the bird’s magnetic sense. When the huts were screened from that noise, the robins oriented normally again. The noise was far too weak to harm anything, but it seemed enough to disturb a delicate sensor. This supports the idea of a quantum based magnetic sense sensitive to tiny disturbances. Though the exact mechanism is still being investigated, a sense so subtle that the quiet hum of our devices can blur it. The search for a bird’s magnetic sensor took an unexpected turn. For a while, scientists thought they’d found a magnetic sensor in pigeons. Clusters of ironrich cells in the upper beak looked like they might act as tiny compass needles, detecting the field through magnetic iron.
But in a study published in 2012, researchers took a closer look and found that those ironrich cells were actually immune cells, a kind of cell that collects iron as part of the body’s normal housekeeping. They weren’t nerve cells, and they didn’t seem to be sensing magnetism at all. It was a humbling moment and it shows how difficult it has been to locate the magnetic sense precisely. The compass is clearly there. Finding exactly where it lives has proven remarkably elusive. Sea turtles seem to inherit a magnetic map. Young loggerhead sea turtles hatch on beaches and crawl into the ocean, then set out on a migration that can span an entire ocean basin. They do this without parents to guide them. Experiments suggest that these young turtles appear to inherit a magnetic map. When exposed to magnetic field patterns found at different points along their ocean migration route, they respond by swimming in directions that would keep them on course.
Adult turtles and salmon seem to use magnetic signatures to find their way back to their home regions years later, returning to the same coasts and rivers where they began. A map not drawn on paper, but woven into the field itself and carried in the instincts of the young. Some bacteria build their own compass needles. In 1975, the American microbiologist Richard Blakemore described bacteria that swim along magnetic field lines. These magnetotactic bacteria build chains of tiny magnetite crystals inside their cells, the same mineral that makes up load stone. Each crystal is a tiny permanent magnet, and lined up in a chain, they act as a built-in compass needle. The whole cell turns to align with Earth’s field as it swims, much like a compass needle floating on water. Because field lines tilt into the ground, following them helps these bacteria swim downward toward the sediment where they prefer to live. Single-sellled life carrying the oldest kind of magnet humans ever found, tucked inside its own body.
Dogs may line up with the magnetic field, but the evidence is mixed. In 2013, a study reported something charming and odd. Dogs tended to align their bodies roughly north to south when relieving themselves, but only under calm magnetic conditions when Earth’s field wasn’t being disturbed by activity from the sun. It caught a great deal of public attention, but later attempts to confirm the finding have produced mixed results. Some studies saw a pattern, others didn’t. It’s a good example of how science works. An intriguing result appears and then others try carefully to see whether it holds up. For now, whether dogs truly have a magnetic sense remains an open and rather endearing question. Human brains may respond to magnetism without our noticing. In 2019, researchers at Caltech placed volunteers inside a specially shielded chamber where they could control the magnetic field precisely. They rotated a field of the same strength as Earth’s around the participants who sat quietly in the dark.
In some participants, the rotating field changed their alpha brain waves, a pattern of brain activity, even though they didn’t notice anything at all. This is being discussed as possible evidence of an unconscious magnetic response in humans, but it hasn’t yet been confirmed by independent replication. It’s possible that somewhere in our own bodies, there’s a faint trace of the sense that guides robins and turtles working quietly beneath awareness. Or it may turn out to be something else entirely. The question is still open.
Chapter 27: Conclusion
Tonight, we followed a small magnet on a door all the way down into the heart of matter. We found that holding still costs nothing, that a field can grip and guide without spending, and that every loan of energy is eventually repaid. We found that you can cut a magnet forever and never hold a lonely pole, and that one strange signal on a February night in 1982 still waits, unreped, for an explanation. We met electrons that carry their magnetism without being fed, settled in quiet quantum states that never run down, held in line by the electrical push between them. We saw how magnets lose their order to heat and force and time, and how some rocks have kept theirs for more than 3 billion years. We traveled down to the churning metal of Earth’s core, up to the shimmer of the auroras, and into the eyes of a small bird finding its way through the night. A magnet never runs out. Not because it holds an endless supply of energy, but because it was never spending any. Its strength is not a fuel.
It’s an arrangement, an order, a pattern of countless tiny magnets all pointing the same way. And order like that can last for as long as nothing disturbs it. So as you rest now, you can let that thought settle gently. Somewhere in your home, a small magnet is still holding on. Far below you, liquid metal is still flowing, still weaving the field that wraps the planet. Overhead, that field is quietly steering particles from the sun. And inside every atom of your body, electrons are resting in their steady states, asking for nothing, simply being what they are. Before you drift off, here’s a small question to carry with you. If you could see magnetic fields with your own eyes the way a robin might, what do you think the world around you would look like? You can share your thoughts in the comments. And if this gentle journey helped you rest, you can subscribe so more quiet explorations like this one find their way to you. Sleep well and let your thoughts settle softly like iron filings coming to rest along invisible lines.
stock here: I think this is statistically significant…..

https://www.yahoo.com/news/20-people-including-9-wisconsin-211130221.html?guccounter=1
stock here, you can find this as a Vitamin too. The real thing is better.

stock here: meant to be funny a little, the last def is to use literal in a way that is clearly not literal, that it is <sarc>.
If we could just be unburdened by what has been…….
Fake Intellectualism, LIKE THIS

Why People Overuse and “Misuse” It
The Real Meanings of “Literally”
According to major dictionaries like Merriam-Webster and the Oxford English Dictionary, the word operates with a few distinct definitions: [1, 2]
stock here: I am guessing this is California….more of this under “Democrat ‘Leadership'”
Why do they think they have a right to do this? https://t.co/NXXmEJrbDR
— Larry Dean (@larry_mcwethy) November 15, 2026
stock here: The Democrats fought to block every common sense rule that would mitigate vote cheating. And the Republicans have knowingly and willingly been such feckless C$$TS that they are accepting these losses as real and deserved. Well they are deserved, but that does not mean you hand the country to the communists.
The spreadsheet is my effort. Very few of these races were close, the 2 close ones, Republican won. Independents were all running against Republicans, and they all lost.

In the House, it was also a strong Democratic showing. But more than half of the Dem spread is related to California. 1 out of 7 were close races under 5% spread….Rpublicans took 41 of the close races compared to 27 by Democrats.


Close

stock here: I have never seen a side view of this guy, maybe he tries hard to not let that happen lest we see the hooked nose. When you need real shitty things to happen, you put these types in charge.


Do you trust that man above? Sorry but my countrymen gave him 72% of the vote.
——————– And this character on Maui….

stock here, preseving this important info.
Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for morePutin Raises the Stakes: Ukraine Is No Longer the Whole NegotiationMoscow has put NATO’s military posture and Europe’s security order back on the negotiating table. Brussels has chosen its team. The Kremlin has not agreed to give it a seat.The Duran InsiderNov 14 READ IN APP Subscribe to The DuranThe Kremlin meeting of 12 November between Vladimir Putin, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner produced no ceasefire breakthrough. It did something more consequential: Moscow put the military architecture of Europe back at the centre of the negotiations. What began as a discussion of how the fighting in Ukraine might stop is now being framed by Russia as a negotiation over the strategic arrangements that followed the Cold War.In his briefing after the meeting, presidential aide Yuri Ushakov said Putin had revisited the draft security agreements Russia presented to Washington and NATO in December 2021. These called for an end to NATO enlargement, limits on weapons systems near Russia and a return to the alliance’s force configuration at the time of the 1997 NATO-Russia Founding Act. Ushakov added that Moscow wanted to introduce further considerations drawn from the conflict since 2022, but did not specify them. The significance is not that an old document has resurfaced; it is that Moscow has restored its most contentious provisions to the live diplomatic agenda.That is the central shift. Ukraine remains the immediate subject of the war, but the Russian proposal treats Ukraine’s future as inseparable from the rules governing NATO deployments, security guarantees and the strategic balance across the continent. It is a bargaining position with consequences far beyond Kyiv. What ‘back to 1997’ Actually MeansThe date matters. The NATO-Russia Founding Act was signed on 27 May 1997, before NATO’s major eastward enlargements. The Russian draft of December 2021 went further than the Founding Act itself: Article 4 proposed that Russia and the states already in NATO in May 1997 refrain from deploying forces and weapons in other European states beyond levels present on that date, except by mutual consent. The draft was never agreed. Calling this a demand to push NATO ‘back to the German border’ captures the scale of Russia’s proposed retrenchment, but it is not the text of a negotiated agreement. It concerns force deployments and weaponry, not the automatic expulsion of Poland, the Baltic states or any other NATO member. Nor did the 1997 Founding Act itself require an across-the-board withdrawal of all allied forces from Eastern Europe. Its language addressed, among other matters, additional permanent stationing of substantial combat forces in the security environment of that period. For Moscow, revisiting 1997 would institutionalise limits on NATO’s military reach. For countries that joined NATO after that date, the proposal would constrain the practical value of their alliance membership. Washington cannot simply sign away deployments in allied countries on their behalf. The proposal therefore turns the debate into a test of NATO’s internal unity as much as a negotiation with Russia.Ushakov’s reference to additional Russian demands deserves attention, but not invention. The Kremlin has not publicly specified a new list requiring Nordic countries to leave NATO or any comparable change in membership. Such possibilities may be debated by commentators; they are not established negotiating terms. No Western Troops in Ukraine: The Red LinePutin’s other direct message was directed at Europe’s proposed post-war security arrangements. He rejected the deployment of foreign military contingents in Ukraine and warned that they would be treated as legitimate military targets and could trigger renewed fighting. That is the Russian position; it is not a rule of international law determining the status of any future mission. The dispute exposes a fundamental collision. For Kyiv and its European supporters, a durable settlement requires credible guarantees against another attack. A multinational presence is one option they have explored. Moscow describes the same arrangement as the continuation of the military threat it says it is fighting to remove. A formula that one side calls a guarantee, the other calls a reason to resume war.This cannot be resolved through a change of terminology. Relabelling troops as monitors, peacekeepers or members of a coalition does not answer who authorises them, what weapons they carry, who commands them, whether Russia consents and what happens if they come under attack. Each question goes to the enforceability of any peace agreement.Upgrade Your SubscriptionKostiantynivka: A Humanitarian Proposal and A Contest Over the MapPutin also proposed a temporary humanitarian operation in Kostiantynivka, inviting outside journalists to observe evacuations and, in the Kremlin’s formulation, establish who controls the contested city. Ushakov said Witkoff and Kushner supported further discussions. Moscow is therefore using a seemingly limited humanitarian initiative to challenge Kyiv’s battlefield account in front of the Americans. There is, however, a substantial factual dispute. Russian officials claim effective control, whereas the Institute for the Study of War reported on 13 November that Ukrainian positions remained in and around Kostiantynivka and that Russian forces had not captured the city in full. Ukrainian officials also expressed concern that a pause could allow Russia to regroup. Neither the Kremlin’s claims nor the suggestion that Kyiv would necessarily refuse an independently supervised evacuation establishes control of the entire city. The proposal nevertheless has diplomatic utility for Russia. It puts the humanitarian question, the credibility of competing battlefield maps and the burden of explanation onto a single stage. If pursued, the test should be practical: neutral access, independently verified ceasefire arrangements and protection for civilians, not a media spectacle presented as proof before observers arrive.Kushner’s Promise and the Kremlin’s ConditionA second dispute concerns who will actually sit at the table. After Moscow, Kushner said the next round of talks would include European partners. Russia’s published briefing did not explicitly endorse that arrangement. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov subsequently said European participation in an expanded format would be considered once Moscow saw a genuine intention and readiness to contribute to peace. In short, Washington described inclusion as agreed; Moscow described it as conditional. That discrepancy matters more than the diplomatic optics. If the United States is advertising a concession Russia believes it has not made, the next meeting begins with disagreement over who has permission to attend. But the public record does not establish that Kushner intentionally misrepresented Putin. The possibility of private understandings and different interpretations remains; what is verifiable is the gap between their public positions.The same problem appears in the proposed sequencing. Kushner has spoken of addressing territorial issues and the broader European security settlement alongside one another. Moscow is seeking to link them, using the prospect of a Ukrainian settlement to press for larger concessions. The Europeans insist on the reverse order: an initial ceasefire, then a peace agreement, then discussion of the wider security architecture. Kaja Kallas made that sequence explicit in Dublin on 12 November. Europe Has a Team, but Not An Agreement on the TermsThe struggle over Europe’s representative also moved on after the first reactions to the Moscow meeting. At the Dublin summit on 13 November, EU leaders rejected a single chief-negotiator solution and agreed on a team comprising EU institutions and the E5: France, Germany, Britain, Italy and Poland. European Council President Antonio Costa said the group would coordinate its position, while security guarantees would be handled through the Coalition of the Willing in coordination with NATO. That decision matters. It gives Paris and Berlin a national role, brings Warsaw into discussions affecting NATO’s eastern flank, includes Britain despite its position outside the EU, and leaves EU institutions inside the process. It also avoids granting sole authority to Costa, Macron, Merz or Kallas. Alexander Stubb remains an active diplomatic voice, but the Dublin decision did not appoint him as Europe’s chief negotiator.It does not, however, settle the substance. The same team includes governments with different threat perceptions, military capacities and priorities. More importantly, organising a European delegation is not the same as securing Russian acceptance of its presence. Nor is the creation of a negotiating team evidence that Europe has accepted the Kremlin’s demands. Costa has argued that only Ukraine can decide matters concerning its sovereignty and territory. Kallas says the present security architecture rests on agreements Russia itself has endorsed, and that a ceasefire must come first. Moscow, by contrast, wants the broader security discussion to determine how a settlement in Ukraine can be sustained. Behind the argument about chairs sits the harder argument about the agenda. The Real Negotiation is Over Sequence and LeverageThree strategies are now visible. Moscow wants the European security question settled as part of, or before, the Ukrainian endgame. European governments want fighting halted and Ukrainian guarantees established before institutionalising any change to the continental order. Washington is attempting to keep both questions alive, potentially on parallel tracks. Each ordering shifts leverage, risk and the obligations that must be delivered first.A ceasefire negotiated without agreement on what follows may leave Russia and Ukraine facing precisely the security dispute that produced the war. A comprehensive security negotiation conducted while fighting continues gives Moscow more opportunity to apply pressure through military operations. Parallel tracks may offer diplomatic flexibility, but they also create an opportunity for one side to bank the benefits of progress on one track while blocking the other.This is why the military situation matters, but it must not be reduced to certainty. Russian forces continue offensive operations, and Ukraine faces pressure, yet the claim that total Ukrainian defeat is imminent is an assessment, not an outcome established by the available evidence. The Kremlin is seeking to convert perceived battlefield leverage into permanent political and military constraints on NATO. Whether it can obtain those concessions is another matter. The practical test of the next round is not a smiling photograph or the number of delegations in the room. It is whether the participants can agree who speaks for whom, what is being negotiated, how a ceasefire relates to security guarantees, and which commitments NATO countries would actually have the authority to implement.Putin has enlarged the price of a settlement. The Kremlin’s reference point is 1997, its leverage is the continuing war, and its objective is to shift the discussion from Ukrainian territory to the balance of power in Europe. The European Union has now organised its negotiating team, but has not reconciled its ceasefire-first approach with Moscow’s insistence on security architecture first. Washington has promised inclusion without an unambiguous Russian endorsement. Until those disagreements are resolved, the central obstacle is not the absence of another meeting. It is that the parties are still contesting the terms on which a genuine negotiation can begin. |
stock here: I wonder if they get banned, I was put on a 7 day suspension for speaking truth. They hate truth.
——-

58m·Cedar Pointe
Well not to sound like a nut job but whether you know it or not American society has been set up for the creation of divisions in our society this through the use of social media and advanced technologies many of which the public’s not even aware of. You have to trust me on this but Facebook Instagram tiktok and all the rest are not set up to make money as much as they are to try and divide our society.
Whoever they is, and many of us have a pretty good idea of who they are LOL, they have concluded that it’s in their best interest to keep us from being unified :-).
The internet now along with all the various forms of media is there now to foment hate on both sides. And now with AI getting involved, they’re able to do so much more when it comes to predictive programming of people and how to manipulate them to achieve their goal.
Again you may call me a nut job, but the proof is in the pudding right? And if you just take one look at what’s happened and is happening in our country, we live in two separate countries. Believe me we all know how to do this on a small scale with our family and friends right?
All you have to do is lie to somebody or make up a story and spread it and you will have people mad at each other, causing deep divides and hurt that for many people is seemingly impossible to overlook and forgive.
Part of overcoming this is knowing that you’re being manipulated. And when you know that you have knowledge and you know what they say about knowledge. 🙂
stock here:

TODAY
stock here: This is part 1 of 2 parts. Brett started out the Pandemic as a “true believer” also the “vaccines”. He is the one in 100 that can actually change his mind when presented with new truths.
A-Eye Summary
Bret Weinstein: Hidden Power, Institutional Failure, and the Future of Western Civilization
In this wide-ranging interview with John Papola on Dad Saves America, evolutionary biologist Bret Weinstein examines what he believes is a growing disconnect between democratic institutions and the people they are supposed to serve.
The Epstein controversy provides the starting point. Weinstein questions the Trump administration’s reversal in its approach to releasing information and raises the possibility that compromising material could be used to influence powerful people. He argues that such influence, if substantiated, would threaten the principle of government by consent.
The discussion broadens into institutional dysfunction, particularly in government, universities, and scientific research. Weinstein argues that organizations can develop incentive structures that reward conformity, discourage dissent, and protect established elites rather than pursue their stated missions.
Papola introduces another dimension: the internet has made institutional failures increasingly visible while allowing powerful networks and communities to operate across national borders. Both speakers explore how technology is transforming traditional concepts of citizenship, friendship, and political accountability.
Their discussion of globalization, immigration, and pandemic policies returns repeatedly to the question of whether governments genuinely represent the interests of their citizens.
The interview’s most important philosophical conclusion concerns the meaning of Western civilization. Weinstein defines the West not principally by geography, nationality, or ancestry, but by reciprocity, individual merit, and cooperation across inherited divisions.
He argues that humanity faces a choice between a future organized around common civic principles and one driven by competition between ethnic, religious, or ancestral groups.
The central message is that a functioning civilization requires trustworthy institutions, meaningful accountability, and an ability to place shared human values above inherited group loyalties.
Important distinction: The interview contains speculative claims about intelligence operations, COVID-19, climate science, immigration, and coordinated political influence. These are the speakers’ arguments, not independently established findings. The broader institutional and philosophical questions can be considered without accepting every factual premise advanced in the discussion.
——————————————————————-
|Full Transcript
Bret Weinstein on Epstein, Institutional Trust, Globalization, and the Future of the West
Dad Saves America — John Papola in conversation with Bret Weinstein | Part One | Approx. 88 minutes
EDITORIAL NOTE Edited from the supplied automated transcript; timestamps and most verbal fillers removed, obvious caption errors corrected, and chapter breaks added. The source audio was not independently reviewed. Speaker attributions and uncertain caption wording may require checking before publication. Opinions and allegations are those of the speakers, not independently verified facts.
John Papola [00:01] Bret Weinstein, welcome back to Dad Saves America.
Bret Weinstein [00:01] Great to be with you again.
John Papola [00:08] I’m sorry that your lovely and brilliant wife can’t join us this time, but we’ll have to do just the two of us and there’s a lot to talk about. So I want to start off with a snapshot because we are now as we sit here, you know, the better part of a year past the halfway point in the first year of this new Trump administration and there was a bunch of stuff going on that seems like it has gotten better and some things that have gotten strange and I’m just curious your take on it because you know you really you really came out and said this election is a pivotal moment for like the course of our civilization. Do you feel like that’s still true? Give me the snapshot.
Bret Weinstein [00:57] Yeah, the snapshot is I very much feel like we dodged a bullet and what we got is a mixed bag for reasons that I don’t understand and I don’t have the sense that anybody fully understands. But I don’t think there was another option. In other words, I’m perfectly comfortable with how I voted and what role I played and that the right choice was what happened. But that said, I feel like we are watching a movie in which there is a force that we know nothing about that accounts for many of the things that we can see with our own eyes. And so what I’d love to know is what’s going on behind the scenes that accounts for the various successes, failures, changes of course that we are all forced to grapple with.
John Papola [01:59] I that begs the question, what is leading you to believe there’s there’s a there’s hidden forces or they might be emergent. They might not be individuals or maybe they are individuals but what do you mean by that?
Bret Weinstein [02:07] Well, let’s take the Epstein situation. Yeah, it was a funny thing to promise us transparency on that issue to make indications that we were headed down that road, that we were going to see something important. And then a sudden about-face in which the administration swears across the board that there actually is nothing to see and that we should be happy with the other accomplishments of the administration cuz aren’t they wonderful? Something happened behind the scenes. Either they discovered something about what they had that caused them not to want to release it or some leverage was revealed that caused them to realize they couldn’t afford to release it. But I guess the point is if they had said nothing and done nothing, I wouldn’t necessarily infer something important.
But having said we’re giving you this and then making the embarrassing reversal of course suggest there’s simply an element of this plot that we don’t know anything about.
John Papola [03:27] Okay, I’ll keep this quick. Be sure to hit that like button, subscribe to the channel, and ring the bell so you won’t miss more Dad Saves America as our videos come out each week. And it also really helps us because when we reach out to guests, they look at how many subscribers there are to decide if they want to come on and share their ideas. So, please subscribe to the channel. It really helps us out. And thanks for watching. Now, back to the show. It’s a it’s a very strange story on a lot of fronts because it’s an old story.
I talked about this in a recent video that I think the f the first big piece on Jeffrey Epstein was in the New Yorker in like 2002 and it laid out the story of him as this international man of mystery and there was a cartoon charact version of him and Bill Clinton chummy with Chris Tucker and the act the actor whose name is escaping me from The Usual Suspects who got into a lot of trouble for pestery it’ll come back.
Bret Weinstein [04:42] Kevin Spacey.
John Papola [04:43] Kevin Spacey. And this is this is the article where you know Trump is sort of says, “Oh yeah, Jeff and I are good friends and he likes girls as much as I do, you know, and he and he likes them young.” And even saying that in public is weird in 2002, but you’re a playboy in New York, I guess. I don’t know. But it just keeps on going and keeps getting weirder. So, how do you understand what you know about this story? And why do you care?
Bret Weinstein [05:15] Oh, why do I care is the easiest question in the world, which is the what we do seem to know about the story implies a sophisticated operation to collect compromise. There’s some debate as to whether or not he was a freelancer arranging kompromat for his own reasons or whether he worked for somebody. I think it’s a slam dunk that he must have worked for somebody. But the point is this. I don’t the fact of the crimes committed by Epstein and the people that he was involved with is profound in its own right. But even if you put that aside, the important question for us is what role is the Epstein library playing in our governance of our own civilization? Our civilization to the extent that it is a departure from history is based on the consent of the governed which means that we govern ourselves.
But if something has gotten leverage over important people sufficient to cause things that we want not to happen and to cause things we don’t want to happen, then we are not self-governed and we need to know. It is a top priority for us to discover whether or not the amount of steering that is being done with that material is major which I suspect it is or it’s minor and it is you know and the world is roughly as we imagine it should be. So I don’t I don’t see higher priorities than understanding to what extent the democratic nature of our society is a fiction.
John Papola [07:04] Well said. The this is one of the elements of the new world we’re in that is so difficult to navigate if you see yourself as a truth seeker which is how when do I know that I have gathered sufficient information to be on the path of truth as opposed to caught in a web of lies. So, so you know, specific to this story, like how have you been trying to navigate that? How have you been trying to under and maybe there’s a some generalizable principles for those of us that open up our phones and say, “Holy cow, I don’t know what to believe,” which is to say all of us. But how are you probing into this? What are you looking at? What are you dismissing?
Bret Weinstein [07:55] Well, I would say I am in the lucky position of having spent my life building a toolkit that fortunately works across almost everything. The toolkit is scientific and I don’t mean by that what most people would mean. It’s not technical. But what I do is I build a model, something often that I just hold privately, and I refine that model based on how it predicts things in the world that I couldn’t possibly know. And to the extent that my model has value, it predicts things well. And to the extent that I’ve added something to it that’s incorrect, its predictive power drops off. And so I think we all do this whether we know it or not.
And the question is how good are you at it? and the idea that the Epstein Library, for example, was deliberately collected to shape world events is perfectly consistent with the idea that an administration that was promising to release this material would be opposed at the highest possible strength. On its way towards attaining the office and that upon reaching the office that there would be a strange turn a turnabout in which the materials would not emerge. So I guess the point is there is hidden leverage and those who have it will do anything to prevent its loss and that means that things will get strange. You will see a kind of distortion around some massive object that you can’t detect, but it will cause things to warp. And that’s exactly what we see every time in the Epstein case.
John Papola [10:05] Yeah. I mean, one element of what has happened with this that is really strange is I mean, it’s historically strange to have this gap between presidencies, right? to have Donald Trump come into office in 2016. And all the facts of his understanding, knowledge, experience with Jeffrey Epstein are already known and haven’t changed since. To then for him to come out of office to be prosecuted and persecuted with what looks like every tool his opponents have at their disposal. I guess save for this one, which is weird. If there is a tool against him that they could have used, why wouldn’t they have?
And then for him to come back into office having already been in the presidency and on the way in making promises about this material, which at in the prior period, he technically, I guess, should have had enough power to know what was there. And now we’re back and there’s this turnaround. And that sequence is really weird because it’s like, well, why didn’t the Democrats use it against him for the past four years? Why would he and his surrogates make promises about releasing it given that he should have known what’s in here in the prior period if they knew they couldn’t do that? So, flesh that out for me, cuz this is this is the part of this that is really kind of crazy, actually. I think this part’s easy, actually.
Bret Weinstein [11:44] Oh, okay. Let’s imagine that the cartoon view of what’s taken place is roughly right. Just broad brush. That Jeffrey Epstein was a front for an intelligence operation. Maybe one intelligence service, maybe multiple intelligence services, probably the latter, but whatever. There’s some hidden entity that enjoys a permanent advantage in terms of information and that it went about collecting specifically useful information through Jeffrey Epstein his connections and his ability to parasitize the worst aspects of human character etc. Okay, so you’ve got a pile of leverage points. First of all, you would want to use them as sparsely as you could.
You don’t want to define the leverage that you hold because somebody who is playing against you, who understands exactly what you hold, has a useful piece of information in its own right. So you would want to use it sparingly. In each case, you would never want to get to the bottom of the barrel where you’ve thrown everything at somebody that you wish to leverage and you have nothing left because at that point the incentives of the person who you’ve gone after with this piece of leverage has nothing left to lose and they turn on you. So you would imagine that there would be a kind of a hierarchy of leverage and that especially with a character like Trump. And I’m not saying that there are things about Trump himself in the Epstein library. I of course have no idea. They obviously had contact.
Maybe let’s just say I’m I’m not arguing that Trump is in there in the way that we fear others are, but like Prince Andrew for example, right? Like Prince Andrew for example. But if you had a character like Trump who had proven that he was capable of leaping levels of the game and changing roles radically and defying expectations, the last thing you want to do is take whatever leverage you have and throw it all at him and hope it works. Because if it fails, now you’ve basically injured the grizzly bear and you don’t have any ammo left. And you would exposed your
John Papola [14:37] tool set, right? That’s the other piece is that you’re in doing that, you’ve now invited the game to be fully revealed.
Bret Weinstein [14:47] Absolutely. So, what you would do is you would have a kind of this is the you know break glass in case of emergency piece of leverage that we are going to hold back if the worst comes at us. What would the worst be? Oh, that the president himself is interested in revealing the leverage war chest and that would be I mean just put yourself in the position of its owners that would be apocalyptic. So you would have something and whether that is a threat, a credible threat or it is a revelation of compromise on people that Trump can’t afford to lose or is emotionally connected to in a way that he would fall on his sword to protect them. Who knows what it might be?
But let’s just say a an intelligence service which would have a virtually unlimited budget to create leverage would know a great deal about what would work to persuade Trump. They would have invested heavily in analyzing him, what wouldn’t work. And you know the about-face Pam Bondi telling us was on her desk and she was ready to go and then Dan Bongino and Kash Patel telling us, “Hey, you know, it all is on the up and up. We’ve looked at the file. He killed himself.” That was such a strange episode. I think the most parsimmonious interpretation is that there was chaos in the administration as they grappled with the fact that something that they had planned to do was no longer going to be done. And I also thought the president’s tweet was profoundly revealing.
John Papola [16:37] Which one?
Bret Weinstein [16:45] So, maybe it wasn’t a tweet, maybe it was truth social and I saw it on Twitter, but he said effectively exactly what you would imagine that the man we’ve come to know would say, which was, “Epstein’s dead. Get over it. It’s in the past. There’s nothing you’re going to get here, but look at all the other marvelous things that you have gotten and are going to get. And would you really want to put that in jeopardy? In other words, he tried to negotiate with us, not understanding that Epstein isn’t just a list of priorities. Like I said a few minutes ago, knowing the degree to which we do not live in a democratic republic and are being governed by dark forces that collect kompromat and you know cause us not to be able to govern ourselves is a different kind of priority, right?
It’s not a it’s not a alteration in our tax rate.
John Papola [17:44] This is there’s a bunch of different ways I feel like we’re all grappling with what you’re describing. And if to play this back and make sure I’m hearing you correctly, it sounds like what you’re saying is that we are we are in a kind of emperor has no clothes moment. I don’t mean about Trump. I mean about our institutions.
I mean about the nature of at the western civilization America what governs the world what works what’s really going on and there’s a couple things and ideas that have in have scrambled this for me certainly one of which is Martin Gurri’s book The Revolt of the Public now he’s a CIA media analyst and so there’s that but I’ve had him on the show he’s a friend of mine now and his basic premise in that is that the internet and its sort of radical information tsunami has stripped the elite in our society of their clothes. So the emperor literally has no clothes and we get to see it. We get to see Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq which we wouldn’t have seen in the prior periods. We get to see people falling out of the, you know, Harrier jet, you know, wheel wells as they abandon Afghanistan. And we watch it in real time.
And so this has produced this profound level of distrust in the institutions and the people and the leadership. And it is distrust that is warranted because they’re not trustworthy. And we get to see it. And so there’s two ways I look I think about that. One is they’ve always been this corrupt and what’s new is we’re getting to see it. And that’s a sociological social evolutionary thing that we’re getting hit by kind of like when the printing press came out. And this is just one more example of that. JFK was basically coercing underage girls to have sex with people in the pool at the White House. This is not new being engross. But I think you’re saying something different than that, which is that there’s a change that’s going on. Or are you are you saying maybe it’s not a change?
Maybe we’re just having this the scales fall from our eyes and this is just a really acute way for it to happen.
Bret Weinstein [20:17] Well, like I said, my job is to build a model that predicts. I can say with high confidence that our institutions are beyond catastrophically dysfunctional. That part of the model predicts reality with such consistency that I have no doubt about it. There is a question about how far back that goes. Yeah, I can say I think it’s gotten profoundly worse over my lifetime. I think I’m old enough. I’m 56 and I think I’m old enough to barely remember functional governance. And I think that most of my life, certainly all of my adult life has been lived under what I would call entirely malignant governance, which gives people the impression that actually you’d be better off without government because it’s effectively, you know, a big spreading tumor.
And yeah, you’d be better off without the tumor, but you wouldn’t be better off without the thing that the governance built initially. And you know, I don’t know. Did it does it go back to 1963? Was there a coup in 1963? And the people who took power have never relinquished it. That is one possibility. And in that story, I would say Trump is the possibly unique departure where something that they did not control took power, which legitimately troubled them because they had built emperor-like powers into the presidency and suddenly those powers were going to be in the hands of somebody that they didn’t control. That’s terrifying if you’re if you’re that sort of person. So the institutions
Bret Weinstein [22:07] are effectively Potemkin at this point that you can be certain of.
John Papola [22:07] And just for clarity because this word we use institutions can become this sort of like empty vessel. What do you mean when you say institutions?
Bret Weinstein [22:25] well I don’t have a ready definition but I would say they are organized efforts to accomplish things and I would say above a certain scale they’re all preposterous you know and at the moment we see something interesting over in you know the NIH or HHS where we have honorable people who have now gotten command of an institution that it was doing the inverse of its mission statement and are trying to figure out how it works and you know turn it around 180° and so you know is that a dysfunctional institution it’s you know I’m hopeful but it will if they manage it that will be that will be the only functional institution that we’ve got above you know 100 people or something like that. But let’s look at you know pick an example universities.
John Papola [23:24] Yeah.
Bret Weinstein [23:29] Okay. We have universities and they if you walk onto a campus, it sure looks like that they’re doing a pretty decent job of educating young people. So they go into the world with, you know, enhanced cognitive capabilities and that they’re, you know, hard at work studying nature and discovering what makes us healthier and all that. If you look at the product and you test it, you know, do they actually make people smarter? No. There’s a pretty credible argument they make people dumber on average. And the quality of the research actually it is almost all unrepeatable.
John Papola [24:09] Yeah.
Bret Weinstein [24:09] And you know, we first we first got wind of this with the replication crisis in psychology and then the social sciences. And we what we discovered was that literally half or more of the results that we thought were true about human psychology, you couldn’t get the same result a second time. Meaning, no, it was never true. So, oh goodness, is that, you know, an embarrassing failure of one field while all the rest of them are humming along? No. Actually, I promise you, point that lens at any field and you will see it. Because what you’ve got at the very least is a competitive environment in which cheaters actually rise faster academically than people who play the game honestly. And so what you have is a system that becomes a test of how well you can cheat.
And so, okay, that accounts for one of the things about the university system that makes no sense. You have all of these collections of people trained at different times in different ways who had different developmental histories. These people should profoundly disagree in every discipline about all of the stuff that, you know, we don’t yet know for certain. And yet, if you go to Harvard, you will get the exact same stuff that you would get at your local community college. It’s like a McDonald’s hamburger, right? It is a perfectly consistent product delivered with very different aesthetics of the buildings. And that does not make sense. A proper university system would not look like that. Harvard’s biology department wouldn’t look like Yale’s, wouldn’t look like the community college, and yet they do.
And what’s more, when you look at what it is that they agree on, a lot of it is just preposterous. Not a single university in the country had its biology department stand up and say, “You know what? We’re sympathetic with people who have profound unresolved gender dysphoria, but that doesn’t change the biological nature of sex and there are only two sexes and you can’t switch between them.” Right? Not a single one, not a single medical school said that, right? There’s no university that departs from the phony consensus on climate change. Not one. Right? So what is going on that basically what you have is received wisdom being distributed as if it was the result of a process of discovery in which fierce disagreements were resolved.
And we now agree on this thing like DNA is the information molecule that governs the production of proteins in the cell. Right? That’s an honest conclusion and we all agree on it for a reason. And yes, there are a few people who might disagree, but that one’s natural. But all of the modern stuff, it is stuff dressed up to look like science and it isn’t. So you know that let me ask you this. Downstream of a university system that is demonstrably phony. Why do we expect the institutions that are inhabited by people who were trained in those universities to be any better and they aren’t?
John Papola [27:37] It is you know you have deep personal experience with this on so many dimensions including its most pathological forms and you know later this afternoon I want to talk to you about that but about the evergreen experience and revisit it for a little bit but I think that the what you’re talking about is so powerful partly because so much of the psychopathy is like the difference between men and women. It is it like we have eyes. Everyone knows there are men and women, male and female. The language of gender assigned at birth is instantly idiotic to every normal human being. And yet the Potemkin village consensus you’re describing holds up. And like the question is how like how does that happen?
Because even on the climate ch change example, there is a story right now and it is a message sort of focus group tested story and that story goes that increasing levels of CO2 right now are giving rise to dangerous destructive and perhaps extinction-level-threatening extreme weather and an increased velocity of extreme weather events. I am pretty sure because the I’ve looked at multiple sources from people that seem like they’re reasonable that just like look at the actual number of incidents of extreme weather events and costs of extreme weather events normalized for changes that you should normalize for. Like of course the cost of a hurricane hitting Miami in 1800 is lower than in 2025 because there weren’t skyscrapers there. So that’s not the weather. Or that’s a change in the value that was at risk.
This stuff’s knowable. So, so we can you can know with relative ease that there’s no correlation currently between CO2 changing recently and extreme weather events. Like that’s known. It’s the data is there from the major institutions that measure it. So, it’s another example of like quickly it’s not as easily getable as there’s men and women period, but it’s not that far off. And yet these narratives persist. So how does that happen?
Bret Weinstein [30:12] Well, that’s a terrifying story because how it happens is through very mundane incentive structures that cause departure from these phony consensuses to be punished. And all you have to do is set up a system in which people who question these things underperform and people who adhere to them and even better build them out as if actually the truth is even worse than you think. Those people prosper and so then selection does the work. Right? You’ve got you’ve got a system in which people are evolved to see certain things and evolved to be incapable of seeing other things and pretend that what they see is the product of scientific worldview. And it is it is the exact opposite. And the terrifying thing is that we actually depend on good information.
When I say that the climate change consensus is wrong, that implies something very frightening which is that we have no idea. We are changing the amount of carbon in the atmosphere and there is a reason. The Arrhenius equation tells us that will trap heat. Is it trapping enough heat to matter? We don’t know. And so my instinct is no. Probably this is not a significant threat. And frankly, we have other threats that are much greater that we are not paying attention to that science would be very well constructed to reveal. And so for us to be obsessed with climate change in even cases where it has no relevance and to not be concerned with for example the migration of the poles and its relationship to changing solar dynamics is it tells you everything you need to know.
We are not going to pay attention to some very real threats that don’t happen to have humans as the causal agent and therefore do not suggest a bunch of draconian changes to what we’re allowed to do. And we are going to obsess about some claimed threats that don’t stand up to scrutiny. Not only do the numbers require you to edit to a very particular slice of history in order to analyze what the temperatures are, but the places that we have long-term temperature data are severely promoted polluted by the tendency of urbanism to have grown cities around them which put out heat. Some of the places that we measure temperature don’t even seem to be measuring temperature anymore yet it’s reported. So I don’t like to be this guy. I trained to be a scientist.
I want to be able to be a champion of the accomplishments of science and I want to say we need to invest in this because it’s you know it’s not perfect but it is it is making us better off by leaps and bounds. But at the moment the thing that looks like science is theater and that means that the real science isn’t being done. And yes, there are certain things where the science is very difficult and we’re struggling with how to do it or we would be struggling. But then a lot of the stuff we actually know perfectly well how to study many of these questions and we seem to deliberately avoid it. There’s
John Papola [33:45] the thing that connects our convers our conversation about Epstein and this is that they both point to the world of the elite, the world of a small relatively small group of people who go through in these institutions for you know and come out in a very particular way that seems really strange under this kind of basic scrutiny and really strange to normal people who don’t go through it who whose vision of their life looks something like you know try to get a decent job find a spouse have a family and try to protect that family build that family over time as best you can and enjoy the time that’s enjoyable and not all your life’s going to be that enjoyable there’s going to be plenty of stuff that’s hard but try to make the best of your life you can and it’s not about status seeking We are we all status seek in one way or another, but it’s not like my primary objective is how do I get to be well known or how do I get as many peer-reviewed inbound links on academic review site X? that’s a different mode.
That’s a particular kind of mode to have as your highest order concern. It’s an elite concern. Do you have a theory or do you have a model of the elite or that maybe even is evolutionary in nature? Like how do you think about the is there a unifying theory of elite behavior? You know, Rob Henderson who’s been on the show talks about luxury beliefs. They that seems like one aspect of this that’s some outgrowth of it. How do you think about it?
Bret Weinstein [35:31] Well, let’s leave open the question of whether we know who the elites are, right? We could certainly name some people who are likely candidates, but let’s just leave open the possibility that the elites is a real thing, but that our guess as to who’s in and who’s out is liable to be rough at best. I think you can say the following thing. The idea of a free civilization in which people are liberated to do a great variety of things and where you in general are rewarded for figuring out how to create wealth and the more wealth you create from which we all benefit the better you do. I’m not saying that’s the system will never work perfectly that way, but a system that roughly worked that way is more or less what we think we have or are supposed to have. It’s better than plunder. It’s better than piracy.
John Papola [36:35] Oh, I think it’s marvelous. I’m I am an unashamed defender of the idea
Bret Weinstein [36:42] of the West, which is not a list of countries. It’s a belief that we should level the playing field, liberate people as meaningfully as we can. Everybody should play their cards as effectively as they can. And we should expect and in fact desire people to be differentially rewarded based on how successful they are at creating wealth from which we all benefit. I think you’re not going to beat that system. However you can imagine that for people who have by whatever means through crime or through the production of wealth and doing well by doing good once you’ve attained another level right a level above what almost anybody ever achieves you have a lot to lose. Mhm. And the idea that you might therefore view with some concern all of the various contenders to join and ultimately displace.
In other words, there should be some churn amongst the people at the very top based on the fact that the people at the very top may play their cards badly and disappear from that strata and other people will play their cards well and they will join. And so if you’re in that strata, the question might be, well, what can I do to make sure that I’m always here, right? And you might imagine that collusion would emerge between them and they would say, well, you have the same concern because it’s natural. We’ve attained something. We’d like not to lose it. So, what can we do?
And yeah, there are some, you know, you can be smart and you can play your cards well, and that can stave off your dropping out of that strata for some period, but ultimately, it will dawn on a great many of them that, cheating such that those who are attempting to displace them have a harder time than they might otherwise, would be a reasonable thing. So what I’m effectively arguing is that we little people should, if we’re wise, should want the system that matches the brochure of our civilization, right? A level playing field where everybody has an opportunity, everybody has access to the market, you play your cards as well as you can, and you’re rewarded for making the world better in some way.
And then we’ve got a bunch of people who will naturally wish to conspire against that because built into that description that I’ve just given is a
John Papola [39:24] threat to their position. And I wonder I mean that is really an evolutionary explanation that a system in which everyone is free to join the elites is one in which the elites will take on a perspective in which they wish to limit the scope of that system so that they are not threatened by it. There’s I haven’t read deeply into this the work here, but I know there’s been some interesting writing on that one of the a potentially powerful force in our in human history has been kind of what you’re describing, which is to say fighting amongst elites essentially to protect turf and that and that people who are in a in a good position want to make sure that the people who are immediately at their heels can’t get that next way up.
And then and the and the fallout from the rest of that effort is that a lot more people than just the immediate competitors get harmed by that. But that actually the driving force is the I’ve reached this status point, this wealth status, how I see myself, the circles I’m in. And I don’t want you who are right there two years behind me to take my spot. I’ve seen this in corporate life especially. You know, I worked at Viacom, you know, it’s now called Paramount, but sort of big media corporation. There’s only there’s a very small number of the top spots to become a VP, SVP, etc. And the kind of warfare that goes on inside of that hierarchy is brutal. It can be brutal. And so that is that sounds a little bit like the kind of dynamic you’re describing. Is that is that how you understand it?
Is that another way to look at it?
Bret Weinstein [41:35] Yeah, makes perfect sense. And you can imagine in a corporate context, it means that you might expect the head of a division to hire the most promising people and you might be surprised that’s not what happens because of course the most promising people are in a position to outshine you. And so anyway, you would you would imagine that those institutions have a built-in obstacle to refining themselves in that there are perverse incentives for those who inhabit them. But of course, our democratic republic isn’t supposed to work like that at all. Right? We are supposed to effectively be the hiring authority who puts people into a position and if they don’t do our bidding in office, we’re supposed to throw them out.
Of course, the way the game evolves in the case of our democratic republic, we are effectively prevented from having reasonable choices so early in the process that we are forced to choose between unreasonable choices, all of which are effectively acceptable to the elites that haunt our system. And we it would we would be wise to break out of that dynamic.
John Papola [42:54] Yeah. One of the in the case of something like Viacom as an example or even in theory universities although the universities represent an alternative argument but maybe not you have you have laziness self-defeating prisoner’s dilemma nonsense that gives rise to people protecting turf and ultimately not producing value for others the way they’re supposed to. And what leads that to die is that it still is a boat inside an ocean of competition. And so the Viacom boat runs aground because along comes YouTube and or whatever or the next thing. You know, Microsoft was the most feared monopoly because of its wind its Windows operating system at the end of the 90s early 2000s.
And as we sit here, Microsoft doesn’t manufacture an operating system, design, develop, ship an operating system for phones, which is the far more dominant computing platform. And so the market at large is like that ocean of competition that keeps these sort of corrupting forces inside of a hierarchy from polluting everything. It’s like, okay, well, Microsoft, you got fat and lazy. Steve Ballmer, you laughed when the iPhone came out and said, “Well, it doesn’t have a keyboard, so it’s not a good email machine.” And you turned out to be wrong and lazy and stupid and you got destroyed. Our politics doesn’t work that way at the national level because there is no competitor. Those are just called other countries.
And as the best I can understand of what our founders tried to do is say, well, that’s why we should keep the federal government really small and contained. Have there be inter interdep departmental competition? This the separation of powers and federalism decentralize power and authority to these 50 well at the time less but now 50 states such that we’re trying to exploit competition as best we can with a rule set that’s supposed to keep that like within a bound that we still we’re still the country. We don’t fly apart at the seams. But California gets to be crazy and Texas gets to be less crazy and people vote with their feet. Isn’t that still what’s happening? Why is that gone? Why does that why do those forces seem to have started to break?
Bret Weinstein [45:24] Well, I mean, I do think this goes back to the Epstein question and not directly, but my sense is we little people suffer from informational disadvantage that is now being fully cultivated by some force whose name we don’t know. And what that means is that when we look at a map and we see countries with names that we are familiar with and we see borders and we think this is a people and it is governed by a structure, we are effectively signing up for a fiction that does not mirror the reality of what governs this planet. So for example, I cannot answer the question having spent a good fraction of the last 5 years on the puzzle. I cannot answer the question why were we partnered with the Chinese on bioweapons technology.
It does not make sense to me if I think of what I understand to be the Chinese Communist Party, its relationship to the nation called China, the relationship of the nation called China to the nation called the United States. None of these things add up. It makes no sense that we would have been partnered in this way. So what I’m forced to conclude is that there is some entity who I can occasionally detect the action of that unifies some part of the Chinese power structure with some part of some American power structure. Maybe something within the Democratic Party that caused a pandemic scenario that I know to have been mostly fiction to unfold which then allowed a lot of things to be done that had meanings.
You know, I can detect that there was a very smart business play inside of pharma in which a technology that they owned, the mRNA technology, which could not be brought to market because it has a flaw that causes major harm to people who take the technology. Well, they needed an emergency. And so the pandemic, whatever it was, created an emergency that allowed this very profitable technology to become normalized in the public. That is downstream of some collaboration between Anthony Fauci and something he’s connected to and the Wuhan Institute of Virology and something.
So basically my point is imagine that you just had a globe on it with no markings and that somebody was going to sit you down and say let me tell you about the real power players on this map and they were to say the real power players are you know you’ve got people in these five capitals who are collaborating in a some sort of a consortium and this is its this is the name they call it and This consortium has an interest in these five speculative positions in markets that they expect to emerge and it fears the seven things that are owned by this other consortium, right?
Somebody could sit you down and they could tell you, “Here are the real lines on the map and here are the real alliances and every time you say China, you’re being stupid because China is actually divided between three parties, right? you know, there’s the heterodox Chinese Communist Party, there’s the Orthodox Chinese Communist Party, and then there are the Chinese anti-communist or something like that, right? If you knew, if you had just that, you know, day one, you know, here are the real players, here’s what they own, here’s what they think is going to happen, and here are their partners, here are their enemies, right? If you had that, oh, then we could say a lot about why things unfold the way they do. If I have to invoke, well, what do the Chinese think?
That’s like asking, you know, why are the Americans taking the position that they are in Ukraine? And the answer is, I’m an American and I have no idea why we take the position we do in Ukraine. I think the people who know that are somehow they have captured the Democratic party and you know, and half of the Republican party and they’ve got their own reasons. And I have no idea whether this is about resources or it’s about bioweapons research or it’s about a long-term play to create a need for weapons. I don’t know. But I know I know that the lines on the map are misleading me.
John Papola [50:24] Gosh, that makes me think of so many different ways of thinking about that. But when you describe it that way, there’s like one place to push is time and technology and here’s what I mean by that. So we if you go back to the founding of the country, you go back to the founding fathers and try to imagine you’re there. Here you are in this in these colonies and you’ve we think about it like they’re British. We sort of make these sort of modern assumptions about life and about connectivity that aren’t weren’t true. So in reality, you have been there and your family’s probably been there actually for a while, long enough that this is your own home and your connection to Britain is literally letters. There’s no telecommunications. The ship to get you there, the chances you’ll die on it are pretty high.
So you’re not doing that. And if you do it, it’s going to take months. And so your notion of country is very fundamentally physical and embodied and geographic. And it’s in and it’s woven into things that have been part of the human experience forever, which is like family, community, you know, religious, physical practices. It’s physical. It’s a physical reality. We are countrymen in a physical space. It’s geographic. And so you then end up with we want to be our own thing. We don’t like you across the ocean. Now we’re going to be our own country. And we’ve actually kind of been our own country for a long time, which is why this works. And that has been the way humans have lived for forever until you get modern telecommunications.
And now you start to have this ability to have to see and especially in our modern age you can see your community your culture your pe your people my people in a you know cutting AC it’s non-physical like I can be part of a group of people that goes to Davos and my WhatsApp and Signal and iMessage threads are all the people I see in Davos and I could I could pick any group on left right that you know I have groups of things like this of people all around the country that I talk to on a regular basis and that’s and so now I think of them as my people I have my local community but frankly I spend less time talking to my neighbor than I do interacting with people halfway around the world and so that’s a totally new type of social organization I haven’t really thought about it this way but it is it’s like it’s a non it is It’s globalism.
It’s like we’re now globally connected. So, we can have global organizations and global affinity groups. So, it makes perfect sense that, oh yeah, we’ve got these lines we drew from the before times when we were this geographic embodied creature. But, you know, if you get to a certain point, you can you can almost be already be a kind of transhuman whose community is virtual and that you see from time to time when you fly a private jet to Switzerland. Is I mean, how much of that is what is what’s at play, do you think?
Bret Weinstein [53:53] a lot. And I remember I was talking to Heather about this a few days ago. I remember the very predictable articles that were written when Facebook destroyed the meaning of the word friend, right? and it tells a kind of story that we need to know. It’s far from the only example of this. But when Facebook adopted the word friend for somebody that you agreed to connect with, it rendered the idea of friend preposterous because you could have a thousand of them. And the problem is that in the old meaning of the world word friend, you wouldn’t want a thousand of them because you can’t tend a thousand friendships and that means they’re all thin as can be, right? So, Facebook used the wrong word.
But the interesting part of this is that later on we really did evolve into a creature that has honest to goodness virtual friendships. And it didn’t happen all at once. But the number of people in my world who I actually care about and know well who I haven’t yet met in person is not zero. Yeah. Right? You can develop real friendships. You can develop trust because the modality has gotten richer. And so it’s like Facebook stepped on the foothill of something and it was roundly mocked for its use of this term. And I think in some sense should have been because it pretended that those connections were more than they were.
But it hinted at something that happened in the future, you know, a decade or two later that is profoundly important and does explain like imagine that you’ve got the cognoscenti who are the people who realize that the lines on the map are antiquated, that they’re you know some archaic way of viewing social relations and they are enlightened in the sense of oh well my country can be diffuse and here’s its governance structure and here are the people that we care about and try to take care of and that it exists among us. That would that would fit very well with the world I think we detect.
John Papola [56:22] My I mean some of this is not only not harmful but good, right? So, you mentioned you’ve got people that you really care about that you don’t see in person. My son has a friend that left that moved to London when he was in fourth grade and their friendship has been maintained and he doesn’t see him frequently, but he has seen him since. And their way of maintaining their relationship has been through Discord and World of Warcraft or and occasionally playing Magic the Gathering, you know, o over Discord with his webcam looking at his looking at his table. So, that’s great. That’s a that is a good thing. It’s good that’s that was possible when I was a kid. You know, somebody who left the neighborhood to go 30 minutes away because their parents moved, they might as well have vanished.
Like, they ceased to be like I remember I had a friend, Seth, and his parents moved not that far away. Seth vanished from my life and I never saw Seth again because it he they just were outside of the zone of what was like normal ongoing contact that constituted friendship in the halcyon days of the late 80s early 90s. So are we dealing partly do you think with a kind of you know technological social evolutionary process that was inescapable? I want to come back to the question of like forces that are specific and intentional, but leaving them aside just for now. How like what percentage of what we’re grappling with now that sprouts up with things like Epstein and weird globalist stuff is emergent is an evolutionary result of technology and social change.
Bret Weinstein [58:14] Well, I believe we modern humans are confronted with a picture in which we are constantly out of our depth because we have departed from any environment that looks anything like the one we evolved in. Hyper. Not only that, yeah, hyper novel. Exactly. But not only that, it’s hyper novel because the environment that we grow up in isn’t even the environment that we’re adults in. So we’re constantly fish out of water. And the problem with that, as you allude to in bringing up the concept of hyper novelty, is that you struggle to know how to react to things.
And so what you’re describing is a world in which you know am I glad that I can have a honest to goodness friend group that is distributed around the world and that is composed of the people who I think are most I don’t want to say interesting or useful but the things that cause you to want to spend time with somebody I can now pick from a world of people rather than people who just happen to be in my town. Is that a benefit? Yes. However, it comes with the same technology that causes me to lose sleep over the possibility that my kids will get sucked into a totally counterproductive eddy, whether it’s porn or video games or whatever it is that might cause them to tap into some reward structure that is counterproductive, right? That’s not a hazard that we evolved to deal with. And you know, it happens.
It inhabits the same screens. So, I think the net effect of all of this is quite negative, but some of the benefits are so spectacularly positive that it’s hard to realize all that we’ve lost.
John Papola [1:00:23] there be this morning as I was sort of prepping it for this conversation somewhat off-handly I brought something up that I don’t understand that seems like an example of exactly the dynamics you’re talking about and that is it appears to be the case that in the United Kingdom a land whose indigenous people are indeed English and Scottish and Welsh and they’re white they’re Irish they’re white people I don’t care about the lightness. That’s not the point, but it ties into this. You have a dynamic going on that seems shocking and impossible to understand, which is you have a disproportionate amount of fairly heinous crimes in the form of sexual abuse taking place perpetrated by immigrants. And I am Mr. Pro immigration. Every time I talk about immigration on this channel, my viewers are like, “Shut up.
You’re like a liberal.” but it does appear to be a fact that you have largely, frankly, Muslim immigrants in the UK often being forced into small towns, then committing fairly heinous acts with young girls, often in gangs, these grooming gangs. And the police are going after the people complaining about their daughters being raped by Ethiopian and Pakistani immigrant groups who are all basically military-aged men who came over on a boat and were given a check and put up in a hotel at taxpayer expense. And that’s happening enough that you now have movements, which again is also crazy, where across the country, they’re flying their own flags, the flag of their country, and they’re and their local governments are tearing them down because they’re saying it’s hate speech to fly your own flag.
And one other thing I saw recently was they’re sending female police officers around being trailed looking to catch people cat calling them, which is not a crime, but they want to intimidate people. But they’re not doing it in any of the areas that you where that’s actually happening, which are these areas that frankly involve a lot more of these immigrant groups who are coming from cultures that are more misogynistic and treat women more like property. You know, they’re going through like the working-class white neighborhoods and how do you what the hell’s going on? Like, how is the how do you how does your local police person wake up in the morning and do that? Like, and why would the leadership do that? Like, none of it makes any sense at all. You’re it’s it’s England. It doesn’t I don’t understand.
But it but the one explanation is that the governance leadership of that country right down to the level of local small hamlets sees itself as being part of something that has nothing to do with that geography. It’s got some other shared ideology or something. That’s one that’s one explanation. It’s like well this you’re you’re thinking about this like peoples that live in places but that’s not what’s going on. What do you think? What’s going on?
Bret Weinstein [1:03:48] Well, I see that story exactly as you do. It’s unthinkably strange. Horrifying, too, but unthinkably odd that the players would allow it to unfold the way it does. And I want to step back a second to COVID, just because I think this is in some sense the clearest glimpse that we’ve gotten at something. During COVID, we were told a large list of things that we were to do and another list of things that we were to avoid almost to a thing. The lists were reversed.
John Papola [1:04:31] Right.
Bret Weinstein [1:04:32] Right. They wanted to lock you indoors where most people get COVID and they closed the beaches and the hiking trails. Where should you have been? Beaches and hiking trails. COVID didn’t transmit outdoors. The sunlight exposure would give you vitamin D, which was terrifically successful at preventing people from getting COVIDVID. Every single thing was upside down. You can’t get every single thing upside down through incompetence. It just doesn’t happen, right? Incompetent people can’t succeed in figuring out what the correct list is and flipping it. So the point is there’s a reason that you’re getting the inverse of the correct advice at the point that your civilization is doing the exact inverse of what it should be doing if it wishes to be a civilization 50 or 100 years from now.
If it’s one thing, you could say, “Oh, that’s stupid.” But if it’s thing after thing, then the point is well, as they say in military circles, once is an accident, twice as a coincidence, three times as enemy action. And I think the clear message of this is something hostile to what we think of as England has gained an awful lot of control over the governance of the thing we think of as England. And what they want I don’t know but if you just simply imagine well imagine that imagine that England’s enemy had decided to undo England but you know war is too obvious then it would do something like this right I don’t you know how dumb do you have to be to invite, incentivize, and coddle immigrants to your country who hate you. Right? I mean, my feeling is, you know, I have I have mixed feelings about immigration.
My feeling is there is some number of people. I don’t know if we’re above the number of people that we need or below the number of people we need, but there’s some answer to that question. We would be collectively better off if there were more people. Fine. If that’s the answer, legal immigration. Let’s bring in people at the right rate. Let’s not bring them in so that they don’t assimilate because we bring in too many from the same place all at once and so they end up creating a community that doesn’t intermingle. But okay, so you bring in some number of people.
But my first concern would be, do you bring in people who want to be part of our project, who like us, who aspire to earn their way here and will be proud, or are you going to bring in people who literally detest us and would like to see nothing more than our destruction? Right? It’s so obvious. I can’t imagine a well-intentioned structure making this error.
John Papola [1:07:39] It’s it’s it’s it’s a place I find myself thinking about that’s like I had stopped thinking about which because I was in New York for 9/11. I was working in New York City. I wasn’t actually in the city physically on that day. I was in the bus. I was on the bus on my way to New York City from my girlfriend’s house at the time who happened to be a very lovely Orthodox Jewish family. I’m Italian Catholic, but this was my Orthodox Jewish girlfriend. And so I watched the towers fall from their living from their kitchen cuz the bus stopped. I saw them smoking.
I saw the tower smoking and then turned around and I hitched a ride with a lady that was on the bus with me back to Pam’s parents’ house and watched this happen and in horror and like the rest of the country became deeply worried about this Islamic terrorism and al Qaeda and these forces etc. And then after the grinding sort of nightmarish failures of Iraq and the military adventures that followed became sort of disillusioned and came to feel like well maybe this fear about Islam isn’t really all it’s cracked up to be and I don’t really think I trust the people saying we should go into and do all this stuff. So I turned inward and said I don’t want to be involved in any of that.
I got excited about Ron Paul and I put the question of like Islam and all of that kind of out of my head and then along comes October 7 the specifically the responses to it globally on college campuses which suggested things that are really dark. This is before there was a response to October 7. And then I see what’s happening in Europe with the way these kinds of crimes are being handled and the way the governance in Europe is responding to this what seems like fifth column in their society. And it makes me think that whatever this force or forces are they that they have there’s some allies at work. There’s some alliances at work that I also don’t understand.
For example, I don’t understand how anybody could have more than two brain cells and see themselves as both a LGBTQIA plus two spirit whatever activist and be in favor of any Islamic regime or even or ever like how do those two things coexist? How do you get queers of queers for Palestine? That seems like something like some manifestation of a dark alliance that I don’t understand because it doesn’t it doesn’t hold it doesn’t work. Is that part of is that part of this conversation for you? Is that on the radar? Like I know I’m sort of I mean in talking in generalities, but this is this is the lens I’m looking at some of this stuff through and saying like how could this be happening?
Bret Weinstein [1:10:54] Well, look, I know how this is going to sound and I don’t like it any better than you do, but my sense is most people do not have any idea how to think about the present and so they are failing in some number of ways and I don’t get terribly focused on the particular way that people fail. The real question is can we is there a way to think about the present that doesn’t cause you to fail, right? Is there a way that we can be that we can stay grounded and start concluding things that aren’t that are correct and predictive without accepting too much and finding ourselves in that same bucket of failing modes. So look, I see the world through a particular lens that I think is doing that. And unfortunately, it runs a foul of almost everybody, right? Like I have almost no partners in this because well, you’ll see.
Yeah. Okay. The basic idea is we are caught in a battle. It is very definitely a battle of us and them. It’s a battle to the death. I want to be careful to make it clear that I don’t think there should be anybody in the them category, but there are plenty. The battle involves a recognition that human beings can collaborate at the level of civilization based on two principles. One of them is the principle that the west is based on and I want to reserve the right to come back and define the west in a personal way rather than the way most people might. But the west is based on reciprocity and it puts aside genetic lineage. It doesn’t ignore it entirely.
But the basic idea is you should partner with whoever you should partner with because of the characteristics that they bring to the table, not because of where their ancestors come from. The alternative to this is the more ancient form, the lineage-based form in which you are part of a branch of the tree of life and specifically the human branch of the tree of life. And we are divided into different lineages. And the good people are the people from your branch and everybody else is a threat. And you might partner with them, but you partner with them for the purpose of advancing the interests of the branch of the tree of life that you and your kin are from. That’s the old ways. The old ways, they are not the same. The future depends on us embracing the cosmopolitan west.
It depends on us putting aside issues of lineage versus lineage because the lineage versus lineage stuff ultimately involves the displacement of lineage A by lineage B. If you have a planet that’s as technologically advanced and connected as we are and you start playing that game where lineages are attempting to displace each other, it will end with our bloody painful annihilation. So I see the embrace of our willingness to partner with each other irrespective of lineage as the only hope for our future. In that light, the US are the people who are on board with that idea. Yeah, I don’t want to care about where your ancestors come from. If it’s interesting where your ancestors come from, I’m perfectly happy to hear about it.
I’m happy to study who your ancestors have been and what they might have learned, but I’m not going to decide whether you’re good or bad based on who they are. Right? If you’re on board with that, you’re part of us. If your point is not so fast, those people are awful because they believe in this or because they practice that or whatever it is, then you are a threat to humanity until you get over that. So what I see in the Middle East is two parties that have control over their civilizations that are interested in displacing each other. And there are no doubt people in both of those civilizations who given the choice would far prefer to put lineage aside and be prosperous and not fear people based on what language they speak or what gods they pray to etc.
So each of our cultures is a mixture of people who are of these two different modes and our survival depends on hopefully persuading all of the people who are interested in lineages displacing each other irrespective of their story about why in this moment our lineage must displace those other people. We have to either persuade them to join us or defeat them. And my concern about what’s going on in the Middle East is that the lineage versus lineage perspective is dragging the rest of the world in. Which side do you do you side with? And now we’re back to lines on a map, right? Well, is it the people on this side of the line or the people on that side of the line? And my answer is it’s not people on either side of the line.
People presumably on both sides of the line who are on board with the future and then there are people on both sides of the line who embrace a way of seeing things that is hostile to the future and I want those of us who are interested in getting to the future and understand the problem of the other viewpoint to join forces. So what do we do with the LGBTQ person chanting from the river to the sea? Well, that’s a ridiculous failure mode. And you know, we should look at them with some pity because they’re not smart enough to realize that they are completely incoherent and should be embarrassed.
On the other hand, I don’t like the rationalizing of the destruction of an entire population to go after a terrorist organization that the leader of Israel actually argued needed to be financially supported in order to cynically divide the Palestinians. Right? That’s a different failure mode. I don’t like it any better. And so anyway, now you can see why my perspective makes no friends anywhere because the point is whoever you’re signed up with, I don’t like them. I think they’re missing the boat. And the real boat, the one we need to be on, is the one in which we reject. Anybody who’s pushing lineage as the enlightened perspective because it isn’t. It’s dangerous. It is always a threat and we have to reject it.
John Papola [1:18:51] That is that is some thick soup you just served. It is rich. It is thick. It is not watered down, but it is a little coated. And so, I want to I understand exactly what you’re saying. In plain terms it’s like look the whether it’s Israel versus the Palestinians whether it’s sort of you know European Englanders versus inbound you know Muslim immigrants the it is tribal it is it is it is clanish genetic tribalism that is the enemy is that a decent way to summarize it is that how you’re seeing it that if you’re on board with the old ways of clan as defined by my genes and my historical background that’s that is the engine of trouble.
Bret Weinstein [1:19:56] You’re basically right, but I want to make what we’re talking about is so explosive it’s it’s important to get it precisely right. Yeah, we are evolved to displace each other. It makes perfect sense that we would be in light of what we understand about evolution and genes.
John Papola [1:20:15] And when you say displace each other, what literally do you mean? This has nothing to do with humans.
Bret Weinstein [1:20:22] Okay. When a dandelion finds itself spreading into a valley and taking resources, those resources are being denied to the other plants that were growing there before. It’s just simply displacing them. And evolution is a de facto game of discovering exploitable resources and capturing them. So human beings naturally because for the same reason that we don’t have we’re not confused if a father rushes into a burning building to save his offspring. Right? In fact, we can explain that in very simple genetic terms. But the point is that same tendency to view your own offspring with such favor that you will risk your life to preserve them works for populations also. Now I would argue it is good in the case of a father saving his child and it is lethally dangerous when it comes to modern populations of people.
That was necessary in the past. And you will find basically the logic of protecting your genetic kin in biblical texts. If you look at Moses’s laws for war, they line up very well with a recipe for spreading your genes. But you will also find in biblical texts things like Jesus’s story of the good Samaritan in which he basically argues that an individual who would in the past view have been seen as other and not worthy is worthy and should be taken care of despite the distance in his level of relatedness. Right? Should you rush into a burning building to save him? Well, that’s not what Jesus says, but he says two days wages and you know, bandage his wounds. He says, you know, he’s a human being. He’s entitled to be treated as such. And, likewise, the story of, the golden rule, right?
The golden rule is the it is a description of how to view people reciprocally. And you’ll notice that in that telling there is nothing about you know treat people who share your dialect as you wish to be treated. It’s people.
John Papola [1:23:04] So that’s why I mean that’s and it’s high I mean it’s also you know Christ is asked well you know do you accept the laws of Moses and he responds as I understand the text and as I understand the gospels there’s really only two rules really. There’s love God and love your neighbor as yourself, which is a rearticulation of that golden rule, but delivered as a command as a this is what the moral code is to love God and to love your neighbor as yourself. So yeah, I mean it’s very deep.
Bret Weinstein [1:23:43] It’s it is deep and it points towards a future in which we do put lineage aside. We are going in the reverse direction. Mhm. When we are fostering this, you know, I hesitate to say tribal because tribe isn’t necessarily lineage, but in general, they overlap. But when we allow these tribal narratives to justify the destruction of and the displacement of other people, we are falling back into a mode that is very natural in humans. Like I said, it didn’t start with us. It, you know, it’s true of all living creatures, the tendency to attempt to displace.
But the problem is, if you play the human game at this level of technology and this level of interconnectedness in an effort to displace other people with different genes, a you’re doing something stupid because why do you care what the spelling of their respiratory enzymes is? You know, your respiratory enzymes care because that’s how they got into the present. But you shouldn’t care. And so we can turn the amazing story of humanity into a stupid redundant story of genes displacing alternative genes. Right? There’s nothing interesting about that. It’s not honorable. It’s not productive. It is just simply bloody. Or we can say, you know what, evolution played the displacement game. That did make us who we are. It built vulnerabilities into us that we need to be aware of.
But it actually also did something else, something spectacular, which is it endowed us with a capacity to reason and a capacity to hold values that we understand and that can guide us. So we are a unique creature. Our ability to have a value that says actually we prefer peace to war. We prefer others not to suffer irrespective of whether or not they are close kin. That capacity allows us to define a different future and we have been attempting to do it. The reason I don’t like defining the West as a set of nations is that all of the nations that you might put on that list routinely fail to live up to the promise of the West. And sometimes they shine and they succeed at it. And my point is what I’m interested in is here’s what the West is supposed to be.
And I’m interested not in a group of nations that claim to believe that thriving. I’m interested in everybody who actually does believe it pushing their own governance structures in the direction of doing it better so that we can get as close to that ideal as possible. I don’t believe we will ever achieve it perfectly, but we can get close. And one of the things, maybe the prime thing that we have to do is resist the immense gravitational pull of the old ways back into lineage versus lineage displacement games.
John Papola [1:26:56] All right, folks. This is actually part one of a two-part episode. So, next Thursday will come my conversation with Bret, part two. And it is a good one. We dive into his really interesting and unique and frankly somewhat solitary takes on the Middle East and the impacts it’s having on America, American government, American culture, and his own experience of being an American as someone of Jewish descent. They are surprising takes that he’s got and there’s a lot more there and so we talked for a long time and it’s two bites at the apple. So stick around. If you aren’t already a subscriber, be sure to hit that subscribe button so you won’t miss next week’s episode with Bret Weinstein.
stock here: The Midwestern Doctor does some stellar work, and this is one of them. We need to understand “why nothing works inthe USA”.
Trump nicknamed the cutsy “Susie” Wiles, and The Ice Maiden. Interestingly she was born Susan Summerall, daughter of Pat Summerall, NFL player, then commentator.
Calley Means (and his sister Casey Means) rose to prominence following a viral interview with Tucker Carlson, as they presented many of the health points long discussed in the natural health community persuasively enough to reach the mainstream (and hence inspire many more people to look into natural health), after which other large platforms like Rogan also had them on.
Note: having a good message you know well and being able to effectively convey it are two different skillsets, and a major thing the health freedom field has struggled with for decades is having effective media advocates. For example, despite having extensively explored how to “make things better,” I never wanted to be a politician or media figure as I just did not feel I would perform that role to the level it required to be impactful.
After gaining traction, Calley had the opportunity to broker an alliance between Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., then served as a senior adviser at the White House leading MAHA implementation and frequently engaging with the media. On October 22, he resigned without giving a reason,1 though it was reported he was frustrated by the stalled definition of ultra-processed food,1 after which processed food stocks immediately jumped.1
Calley’s core argument is that things get done in Washington in only two ways: special-interest money or public shame. Everything MAHA accomplished (e.g., the psychedelic executive order, the food dye phase-out, the dietary guidelines, and removing soda from SNAP in 30 states) came from the second, often after someone with a large audience made the issue impossible to ignore (e.g., Rogan’s call to Trump on psychedelics). Everything blocked was blocked by the first (money).

stock here: Just saw a great interview on Joe Rogan, and a Admin Insider who quite explains the gatekeepers, Calley Means. Cutsy name like “Bibi” Susie Wiles (prior to Trump, was a top lobbyist taking money from Netanyahu, pharmaceuticals, pesticides, you know evil stuff).One of the deupties was James Blair, Walker Barrett, and recently Richard Walters.
She is a frumpy POS.

The first casualty of the US midterm elections is here, as Trump removes Susie Wiles and promotes Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff. Alex breaks down the shakeup, Vance’s push for an Iran deal, Zelensky’s victory tour and his 16 billion dollar claim, Kaja Kallas rejecting Trump’s European security plan in Warsaw, Rutte admitting Ukraine will not regain its territory, and Russia targeting the Kiev bridges. With Hegseth still on thin ice and Europe defying Washington, who will be the next to go?
This excellent comment gets labelled by a bot as “thanks bot”

hat tip Flying Cuttlefish
stock here: that is not being Misogynistic, that is being politically incorrect. One of the most major differences between men and women, besides the plumbing, is the brain’s ability to operate in 3 dimensions, especially with mutliple objects moving. Men are way better.
Remember that Delta plane that flipped over on the runway…flown by a hot girl with a 50 year old male in the other seat. All joking aside, maybe these girls are distracting the other pilot ALSO.
I just flew through this same type of weather in Florida. We stayed out of all the cells, and there were a ton.

stock here: Listen to Liberty Lockdown for the real Poland Story.
Looks at this bullshit, that at 2AM in late fall, Supermarket freezer went to 50 deg C.
That’s like 120 deg F. Total BS, fear mongering.
And the only Black Muslim Magistrate (Judge) let’s the bad actors at the FBI off the hook
SAme Judge who apologized to Trumps would be Assassin.
How and why does a judge apologize to a would-be presidential assassin?
It’s a legitimate question and one that everyone should be asking after U.S. Magistrate Judge Zia M. Faruqui did exactly that during a hearing for White House Correspondents’ Association dinner shooting suspect Cole Allen. Despite Allen being accused of wanting to murder President Donald Trump, administration officials, and other innocent people, and even though he allegedly shot a law enforcement officer, all Faruqui cared about was the criminal’s comfort level, going so far as not to just care about his jail conditions but actually apologizing to Allen for any inconveniences he may have endured.
=======
Imagine each grocery store employing beret wearing Frenchmen to monitor the temperatures and energy consumption by clipboard to be compliant with the technocratic regime that put small grocers out of business.
Or would they hire ‘new French?’
Regulation (EC) No. 852/2004
This regulation requires food businesses to:
French Order of October 8,2013 – Food temperature control
Mandatory Frenchnationalregulation
Arrêté du 8 octobre 2013
EU Regulation 2024/573– F-Gas Regulation
Mandatory Particularlyimportantforlargesupermarkets
Regulation (EU) 2024/573
This regulation entered into force on March11, 2024, and governs refrigeration systemscontainingfluorinated greenhouse gases.
It introduces requirements including:
French Order of May 9, 1995 –Temperature recording for frozen food
Mandatory in specified circumstancesArrêté du 9 mai 1995
This regulation establishes requirements forfood retail hygiene and temperature control.
It specifically provides for:
French BACS Decree – Buildingautomation and energy management
Mandatory for qualifying buildingsDécret BACS
The BACS requirements concern buildingautomation and control systems.
They require qualifying commercial buildingsto have systems capable of: